{
  "capturedAt": "2026-11-07T21:27:02+08:00",
  "branches": {
    "A": "水的物性与相态",
    "B": "自然与生活联想",
    "C": "造型与角色魅力",
    "D": "ABC 融合",
    "E": "物性 × 调研混搭",
    "F": "ABC 自由拼接"
  },
  "candidates": [
    {
      "id": "A01",
      "branch": "A",
      "name": "融边",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "A01",
          "branch": "A",
          "name": "融边",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-v1-3dcd4e0560.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-v1-3dcd4e0560-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "薄冰正在融化：哑光冰身连接透亮水端，手掌轻垂，目光留意将融的边缘。",
          "versionNote": "薄冰融化；薄冰花瓣、磨砂主体和透明手端；保留红靴。其他候选不以红靴和原花为必要条件。",
          "total": 66,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 20,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "纵长稳定、青暖协调，但正面过对称"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "正面弧笑友善，缺行为目标"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "雾面身亮手可见，融软形不足"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "冰水职责可辨，砂粒亮掌与原岛无验证"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续比例稳，新意依赖微材质，未测小尺寸与制作"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "type": "概念可见性/执行",
              "location": "手端与冰花边缘",
              "problem": "融软重心与薄厚不足，像磨砂版原型",
              "revisionTarget": "保持臂根与长度，让端部轻垂、冰瓣少量薄厚变化，不加纹样"
            },
            {
              "type": "角色方向",
              "location": "双眼与嘴",
              "problem": "展示笑缺少注意目标",
              "revisionTarget": "目光共同关注一侧末梢，轻调嘴角，保持体态"
            },
            {
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "location": "全身材质",
              "problem": "缺原岛及48px检验",
              "revisionTarget": "同镜头同体量原岛核验，控制砂粒与白亮边"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "首轮基线已评，待修订及场景证据",
          "designStatus": "已首评，保留对照",
          "comparison": "",
          "sceneEvidence": "未附当前版本场景结论",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "未附当前版本小尺寸结论",
          "source": "01_首轮评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-small-f9cc838db5.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-small-f9cc838db5-preview.webp",
                "width": 600,
                "height": 160
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "A01",
          "branch": "A",
          "name": "融边",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-v2-59ecf7a17f.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-v2-59ecf7a17f-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "薄冰正在融化：哑光冰身连接透亮水端，手掌轻垂，目光留意将融的边缘。",
          "versionNote": "对应R首轮66分意见：左手下缘明确融垂、双眼共同留意左手、缩短冰花茎并压低砂粒高光；主体不收腰鼓腹。",
          "total": 71,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 20,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "轮廓稳但花与脸仍均匀"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "目光朝左手且嘴平，有担心意图但欠亲近"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 14,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "左掌明显下垂，融化更可见"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "低颗粒改善，仍无原岛；附件：独立逐像素核验：差异仅(491,1310)-(595,1438)，外区原背景保持；大色块体量参考可信，局部草地/角色生成弱化左掌融垂与微表情，不是同模型实装。"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连身短腿稳，花细节未测"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "原岛局部替换区",
              "type": "场景执行偏差",
              "problem": "独立看局部放大并排：矩形内建筑门窗错位、硬拼补边明显；外区像素0只证明范围受控，不证明合成有效。第二轮给的2分场景增益收回，73→71；主体五项回20/13/14/12/12，原主体评价不变。",
              "revisionTarget": "仅修角色/必要接触处；保建筑草地连续，角色形态与主体一致；若当前工具做不到，就明确保留为无可信场景，停止反复整张生成。"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "已R主体复审；场景补看中；暂停精修",
          "comparison": "66→71；融垂和共同注意有实际改善，角色魅力仍欠温暖。",
          "sceneEvidence": "独立看局部放大并排：矩形内建筑门窗错位、硬拼补边明显；外区像素0只证明范围受控，不证明合成有效。第二轮给的2分场景增益收回，73→71；主体五项回20/13/14/12/12，原主体评价不变。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px对照已看v1/v2：融垂与微抿嘴几乎丢失，只保留长身、红足和花小点。",
          "source": "03_定向修订复评评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-scene-e513d9e411.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-scene-e513d9e411-preview.webp",
                "width": 1080,
                "height": 2390
              },
              "note": "独立看局部放大并排：矩形内建筑门窗错位、硬拼补边明显；外区像素0只证明范围受控，不证明合成有效。第二轮给的2分场景增益收回，73→71；主体五项回20/13/14/12/12，原主体评价不变。"
            },
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-small-f9cc838db5.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-small-f9cc838db5-preview.webp",
                "width": 600,
                "height": 160
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "A02",
      "branch": "A",
      "name": "涟帽",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "A02",
          "branch": "A",
          "name": "涟帽",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/a02-v1-ddf206f991.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/a02-v1-ddf206f991-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "水面张力与涟漪：头顶水膜向一侧伸出低檐，水身与暖杏色低鞋形成材质分工。",
          "versionNote": "涟漪张力形成水平水膜檐；光滑长春蓝水身、短臂下放、杏黄低鞋，区别A01融冰花与清水端。",
          "total": 74,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 21,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "蓝紫杏黄协调，帽檐过宽抢体块"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 14,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "侧上望友善但像戴帽展示"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水涟膜檐直观，新意主要集中帽"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水帽有厚度，身仍亮塑料，无原岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "轮廓长身保留，超宽薄檐需远景动作验证"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "涟帽",
              "type": "概念主次",
              "problem": "大环檐像飞碟与身体分离",
              "revisionTarget": "缩檐幅度和圈层，让局部涟弧与顶面连续，保留一个主波峰"
            },
            {
              "location": "面部/身体",
              "type": "角色",
              "problem": "侧望和帽子尚无事件联系",
              "revisionTarget": "选择一处轻偏水面作为注意目标，少量眼神与姿态互相支持"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身/帽檐",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "高光和薄边未验",
              "revisionTarget": "补同原岛及48px，检查宽帽遮脸和穿插风险"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "已R首评；v2精修中",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px已看：涟檐明显，易读飞碟帽，水物性弱。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-small-f9cc838db5.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-small-f9cc838db5-preview.webp",
                "width": 600,
                "height": 160
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "A02",
          "branch": "A",
          "name": "涟帽",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/a02-v2-7d1016bab6.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/a02-v2-7d1016bab6-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "水面张力与涟漪：头顶水膜向一侧伸出低檐，水身与暖杏色低鞋形成材质分工。",
          "versionNote": "按R第二轮74分反馈：撤同心大环盘，收为与头连体的一条低涟弧；目光看左侧低水缘；压亮塑料感。",
          "total": 74,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "大檐收小后主形更顺"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 14,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "侧上望仍友善，事件目标不强"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "环形涟漪几乎消失，变水鸭舌发梢，独特想法减弱"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "反光更柔，紫蓝水与杏鞋清楚，未见本版场景"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "原长身保持，局部檐易辨但核心物性弱"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "顶部局部檐",
              "type": "概念取舍",
              "problem": "减飞碟后涟漪核心丢失",
              "revisionTarget": "不要再加回大环檐；若保该思路，只用一处轻浅水膜张力形说明，不堆多圈"
            },
            {
              "location": "眼神/檐",
              "type": "角色",
              "problem": "仍像戴帽展示",
              "revisionTarget": "选择檐面轻偏一处作注意目标，保持轻微动作"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "本版本原岛未验证",
              "revisionTarget": "补原镜头体量与当前版48px；若独特性无改善可停止"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已复评，按实际缺口修订/保留或停止；非终审",
          "designStatus": "主体、原岛、48px、回应齐备，待同一R实际复评",
          "comparison": "74→74；美感和高光改善，涟漪想法分下降，不能称全面进步。",
          "sceneEvidence": "已看新轮廓并集替换：旧建筑错位已消除、体量接近；旧轮廓草地变软，水涟变短帽舌/蓝紫实体，眼神事件与材质不能精确核。不给自动加分。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "已看新轮廓并集替换：旧建筑错位已消除、体量接近；旧轮廓草地变软，水涟变短帽舌/蓝紫实体，眼神事件与材质不能精确核。不给自动加分。",
          "smallEvidence": "已看v1-v2角色高48px对照：v1圆盘识别强但像飞碟，v2更简洁却像发梢/帽舌，涟漪语义变弱。",
          "source": "03_定向修订复评评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/a02-scene-1aaeaebc59.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/a02-scene-1aaeaebc59-preview.webp",
                "width": 1080,
                "height": 2390
              },
              "note": "已看新轮廓并集替换：旧建筑错位已消除、体量接近；旧轮廓草地变软，水涟变短帽舌/蓝紫实体，眼神事件与材质不能精确核。不给自动加分。"
            },
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/a02-small-f6a17826c2.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/a02-small-f6a17826c2-preview.webp",
                "width": 340,
                "height": 150
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "A03",
      "branch": "A",
      "name": "雪簇",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "A03",
          "branch": "A",
          "name": "雪簇",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/a03-v1-d9cd648aa1.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/a03-v1-d9cd648aa1-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "积雪与压实：偏侧低雪檐、雪团手和清蓝水身，脚端转成冰。",
          "versionNote": "积雪与压实：偏侧低雪檐、雪团手、清蓝水身和无鞋冰足；区别A01薄冰融化与A02涟漪水平膜。",
          "total": 72,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 21,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "白蓝整洁但雪帽手套过像穿戴"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "温和直笑，动作有招呼感但通用"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 14,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "积雪覆盖可读，主要帽和手套符号"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "雪绒与蓝身对比清楚，无原岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续长身与自然下臂成立，雪纹缩小未测"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "雪檐/手端",
              "type": "概念",
              "problem": "雪像帽子和手套，水相态联系弱",
              "revisionTarget": "让一处雪边压实融水，与蓝体连续，减少均一绒面"
            },
            {
              "location": "脸",
              "type": "角色",
              "problem": "直视微笑泛化",
              "revisionTarget": "给雪端或压雪边一处共同注意，不需夸张卖萌"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "缺原岛与48px",
              "revisionTarget": "补实镜头，验证雪白不漂和水身不高亮跳出"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "已R首评；保留并暂停精修",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px已看：雪帽手套清楚，压实融水弱。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-small-f9cc838db5.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/a01-small-f9cc838db5-preview.webp",
                "width": 600,
                "height": 160
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "B01",
      "branch": "B",
      "name": "溪染",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "B01",
          "branch": "B",
          "name": "B01",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b01-v1-9a159d3e59.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b01-v1-9a159d3e59-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水渗润手织布：两侧织岸保留贯通水身，湿纤维向顶花延伸。",
          "versionNote": "",
          "total": null,
          "scores": [],
          "issues": [],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "未找到该图的统一 R 评分，待评",
          "designStatus": "历史过程图，保留对照",
          "comparison": "",
          "sceneEvidence": "",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "",
          "source": null,
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "B01",
          "branch": "B",
          "name": "溪染",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b01-v2-db566947a1.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b01-v2-db566947a1-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水渗润手织布：两侧织岸保留贯通水身，湿纤维向顶花延伸。",
          "versionNote": "",
          "total": 69,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 20,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "青米色有层次，腹侧如护垫"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "友善明亮，缺与花关系"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 14,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "纤维连花可猜，贯通水路不强"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "织物花丝微距感强，原岛未测"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "长身保留，细茎丝花易丢，未制作验证"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "type": "结构概念/执行",
              "location": "腹侧织物与水路",
              "problem": "两块鼓起贴布强于溪流结构",
              "revisionTarget": "压为贴体简面，保贯通水路，以少量定向湿边概括纤维"
            },
            {
              "type": "角色方向",
              "location": "双眼与上方花",
              "problem": "通用笑未支持吸水事件",
              "revisionTarget": "共同目光关注花或吸水线一处，保持纵长比例"
            },
            {
              "type": "细节与证据",
              "location": "细茎花及织纹",
              "problem": "远距离易消失且未验证场景",
              "revisionTarget": "概括主线和花，删除细毛依赖，补原岛与48px"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "首轮基线已评，待修订及场景证据",
          "designStatus": "历史过程图，保留对照",
          "comparison": "",
          "sceneEvidence": "未附当前版本场景结论",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "未附当前版本小尺寸结论",
          "source": "01_首轮评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "B01",
          "branch": "B",
          "name": "溪染",
          "version": "v3",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b01-v3-ba882cbdee.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b01-v3-ba882cbdee-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水渗润手织布：两侧织岸保留贯通水身，湿纤维向顶花延伸。",
          "versionNote": "",
          "total": 71,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 21,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "布块压平，水路更清楚"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "双眼看右下空处，未联到左侧湿线或花"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水与岸结构改善，仍有图案洇边感"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "纹理概括改善，无原岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "长身稳，细花茎仍脆弱未测"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "双眼/湿线",
              "type": "执行偏差",
              "problem": "共同注意移到错误一侧",
              "revisionTarget": "选左侧湿线接点或上方花，双瞳共同准确落点"
            },
            {
              "location": "腹侧湿边",
              "type": "概念",
              "problem": "锯齿渐变像印花",
              "revisionTarget": "减少尖碎湿边，保一条宽贯通水路和贴体岸面"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "场景48px未测",
              "revisionTarget": "补同原岛实镜头，检验花线和水路可读"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "历史过程图，保留对照",
          "comparison": "69→71；腹侧结构改善，目光与事件对应未完成。",
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "未见可对应本版本的48px，不把其他图当本版证据",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "B01",
          "branch": "B",
          "name": "溪染",
          "version": "v4",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b01-v4-34c0173b00.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b01-v4-34c0173b00-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水渗润手织布：两侧织岸保留贯通水身，湿纤维向顶花延伸。",
          "versionNote": "溪水渗润手织布；两侧织岸留贯通水身，湿纤维连顶花；材料关系区别于新候选的苔藓共生或地方生活器物。",
          "total": 73,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 21,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "布岸较平，主水路更清楚"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 14,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "共同低看左侧接点基本建立，仍略担心"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "材料渗润可见，边缘仍像涂色纹"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "低纹理改善，无场景"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续比例稳，细花线未验制作"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "腹侧湿边",
              "type": "材料执行",
              "problem": "仍略像尖舌印花",
              "revisionTarget": "仅保少量定向软湿边，避免继续增加毛丝"
            },
            {
              "location": "眼嘴/接点",
              "type": "神态",
              "problem": "已转正确一侧但尚偏注视自身而无照顾意味",
              "revisionTarget": "保落点，只微调嘴角与手端方向，勿再大幅重做眼睛"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "无本候选场景与动作",
              "revisionTarget": "补B01对应场景，不借用B02图"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "本轮暂缓继续精修，保留已复评对照",
          "comparison": "v3 71→v4 73；目光由错误右下改为关注左侧接点，确有改善。",
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px已看v4：蓝/米/红块可辨，目光与湿线关系丢失，不用于v3。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b01-small-d06d058e25.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b01-small-d06d058e25-preview.webp",
                "width": 32,
                "height": 48
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "B02",
      "branch": "B",
      "name": "苔憩",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "B02",
          "branch": "B",
          "name": "苔憩",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-v1-ac05dd43ea.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-v1-ac05dd43ea-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水与活苔共生：偏心苔枕接侧身苔带，柔软黄绿与清蓝水体相遇。",
          "versionNote": "",
          "total": 77,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "蓝黄绿清新，偏心苔枕有层次"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "侧眼微笑有松弛感，厚睑略困"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水苔共生可读，但头右臂左带分散"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "绒与水对比鲜明，细毛和亮边未验岛内；附件：独立逐像素核验：差异仅(480,1295)-(600,1455)，外区保持。颜色融入；生成背面苔分布与主体有漂移，局部草地重绘，不验精确资产。"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续长身成立，细毛不可当小尺寸识别"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "苔带",
              "type": "概念组织",
              "problem": "头右与臂左打散连续关系",
              "revisionTarget": "选一个主侧收束苔块，另侧只保少量回应，避免双处贴片"
            },
            {
              "location": "眼睑",
              "type": "神态",
              "problem": "略困与松弛难分",
              "revisionTarget": "轻抬睑保侧眼，嘴角保克制，不扩成通用大笑"
            },
            {
              "location": "场景与实际体量",
              "type": "证据限制",
              "problem": "独立逐像素核验：差异仅(480,1295)-(600,1455)，外区保持。颜色融入；生成背面苔分布与主体有漂移，局部草地重绘，不验精确资产。",
              "revisionTarget": "保留已有附件；补角色不漂移、同原背景/机位的核验，检查接地、厚度与原方案特征，不重复声称完全未做。"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "历史过程图，保留对照",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "独立逐像素核验：差异仅(480,1295)-(600,1455)，外区保持。颜色融入；生成背面苔分布与主体有漂移，局部草地重绘，不验精确资产。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px已看：苔枕蓝长身可识，毛丝与眼睑语义丢失。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-scene-d0c2742188.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-scene-d0c2742188-preview.webp",
                "width": 1080,
                "height": 2390
              },
              "note": "独立逐像素核验：差异仅(480,1295)-(600,1455)，外区保持。颜色融入；生成背面苔分布与主体有漂移，局部草地重绘，不验精确资产。"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "B02",
          "branch": "B",
          "name": "苔憩",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-v2-388b510c4d.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-v2-388b510c4d-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水与活苔共生：偏心苔枕接侧身苔带，柔软黄绿与清蓝水体相遇。",
          "versionNote": "",
          "total": 79,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 23,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "苔集中右侧贯通头臂足，整体协调提升"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "侧眼松弛延续，困意仍轻微"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "单侧水苔共生比v1分散块清楚"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "亮边降低，苔毛仍较细，当前场景需核"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "长身稳、大分材面可识，未生产测试"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "眼睑",
              "type": "神态",
              "problem": "松弛仍稍困",
              "revisionTarget": "仅轻抬睑保侧看，不需要换大眼或笑脸"
            },
            {
              "location": "苔/水表面",
              "type": "材料",
              "problem": "微细毛丝和主体柔白易变毛绒拼树脂",
              "revisionTarget": "保大软苔面，少量局部透润说明水，不加密纹"
            },
            {
              "location": "场景",
              "type": "证据限制",
              "problem": "需要核本版单侧苔分布及接缝",
              "revisionTarget": "当前版场景看完整角色和贴补边，不复用v1背面当通过"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已复评，按实际缺口修订/保留或停止；非终审",
          "designStatus": "历史过程图，保留对照",
          "comparison": "v1 77→v2主体79；单侧材料组织实际改进，当前场景另审。",
          "sceneEvidence": "已看根清单最新v2c角色联合范围替换，侧面已可见五官、苔头颊同侧臂；相较旧背面可核更多身份。细苔变光滑、水身偏实体，局部草纹清理仍可见，不证明精确材质/动画，分数79保持。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "已看根清单最新v2c角色联合范围替换，侧面已可见五官、苔头颊同侧臂；相较旧背面可核更多身份。细苔变光滑、水身偏实体，局部草纹清理仍可见，不证明精确材质/动画，分数79保持。",
          "smallEvidence": "已看v2 48px：单侧苔与蓝身可辨，细丝与眼睑语义仍弱。",
          "source": "03_定向修订复评评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-scene-0f2e5c994b.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-scene-0f2e5c994b-preview.webp",
                "width": 1080,
                "height": 2390
              },
              "note": "已看根清单最新v2c角色联合范围替换，侧面已可见五官、苔头颊同侧臂；相较旧背面可核更多身份。细苔变光滑、水身偏实体，局部草纹清理仍可见，不证明精确材质/动画，分数79保持。"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "B02",
          "branch": "B",
          "name": "苔憩",
          "version": "v3",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-v3-fb3685046c.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-v3-fb3685046c-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水与活苔共生：偏心苔枕接侧身苔带，柔软黄绿与清蓝水体相遇。",
          "versionNote": "溪水与活苔共生；偏心苔枕及侧身苔带、雾蓝与黄绿、放松侧眼；没有花、布或鞋。与B01至少核心联想、头身主识别、材料组织和神态不同。",
          "total": 80,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 23,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "单侧软苔大面持续协调，身体不被新细节打断"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "眼开度比v2清醒，仍松弛侧看"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "单侧苔水共生保持，薄端水未变新主特征"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "掌足薄透边略增强，主体仍柔白水冻；场景沿用v2不验新眼"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "大分色保持，48px表情差异需对应检验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "水体薄端",
              "type": "保留取舍",
              "problem": "透润改善集中细边，远看仍可能当实体水冻",
              "revisionTarget": "保本稿，不要求再生；概念交付说明水质假设，后续材质落实再核。"
            },
            {
              "location": "本版场景",
              "type": "证据范围",
              "problem": "当前沿用v2c场景不能验证v3清醒侧眼和透边",
              "revisionTarget": "以结构/体量参考明确标注，不转移表情与材质验收；若本轮不另补，保留这一限制。"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "建议保留v3，不继续盲生主体；二维终审待冻结",
          "designStatus": "v3主体及对应48px待同一R实际复评；v2c场景仅结构参考",
          "comparison": "79→80；清醒眼神确有改善，材料薄端变化小，不为修订次数额外加分。",
          "sceneEvidence": "沿用已看v2c仅作保留结构与体量参考，不验v3眼神及薄边。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "已看v3 48px：分材依然可辨，清醒侧眼与v2差异很弱。",
          "source": "03_定向修订复评评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-scene-0f2e5c994b.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-scene-0f2e5c994b-preview.webp",
                "width": 1080,
                "height": 2390
              },
              "note": "沿用已看v2c仅作保留结构与体量参考，不验v3眼神及薄边。"
            },
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-small-3cda8373be.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b02-small-3cda8373be-preview.webp",
                "width": 32,
                "height": 48
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "B03",
      "branch": "B",
      "name": "溪篾",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "B03",
          "branch": "B",
          "name": "溪篾",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b03-v1-a92b9ef9fb.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b03-v1-a92b9ef9fb-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "水撑弯薄竹篾：顶部低拱与右掌同构，用竹、水和好奇神态组成一个角色。",
          "versionNote": "水撑弯薄竹篾；三低拱与右掌同构、好奇歪眉、小眼无大眼白、低竹鞋；区别于布渗润和苔绒共生。",
          "total": 70,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 20,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "暖竹与水协调，头偏宽重、配件多"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "小眼歪眉有好奇，举手可读"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "竹拱像插把手，水撑竹因果弱"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "竹纹精细、透身无原岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续头身但上重下窄，制作连接与48px未验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "顶部/躯干",
              "type": "比例风险",
              "problem": "顶宽和腋下内收放大头身反差",
              "revisionTarget": "收窄顶部主块、减肩内凹，恢复纵长连续比例；不以开放头部改整身"
            },
            {
              "location": "竹拱/腹侧竹片",
              "type": "概念",
              "problem": "多把手与无作用斜竹片像零件堆叠",
              "revisionTarget": "去腹侧斜片，减为一处明确受水撑弯主拱，与掌拱有节制呼应"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "纹理和连接未测",
              "revisionTarget": "补原岛及48px，检查细竹相交和举臂穿插"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "本轮停止继续生成，保留概念对照",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px已看：竹拱举臂可见，受力不明。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/b03-small-0d518e056d.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/b03-small-0d518e056d-preview.webp",
                "width": 32,
                "height": 48
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "C01",
      "branch": "C",
      "name": "兜住一滴水",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "C01",
          "branch": "C",
          "name": "兜住一滴水",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/c01-v1-459cdbb7c1.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/c01-v1-459cdbb7c1-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "兜住一滴将落未落的水：表面张力形成偏心水囊，目光和抿嘴一起表达专注。",
          "versionNote": "",
          "total": null,
          "scores": [],
          "issues": [],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "未找到该图的统一 R 评分，待评",
          "designStatus": "历史过程图，保留对照",
          "comparison": "",
          "sceneEvidence": "",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "",
          "source": null,
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "C01",
          "branch": "C",
          "name": "兜住一滴水",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/c01-v2-606e65ebbc.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/c01-v2-606e65ebbc-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "兜住一滴将落未落的水：表面张力形成偏心水囊，目光和抿嘴一起表达专注。",
          "versionNote": "",
          "total": 78,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "偏心顶简洁，长白亮带抢眼"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "共同上视滴端有注意目标"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "本体挂滴明确，横向水发歧义"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "上润下哑可辨，喷色感强，原岛未测"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续长身，单滴识别和连接需检验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "type": "概念歧义",
              "location": "右上水囊及滴根",
              "problem": "横向覆盖感像水发，绷住感不足",
              "revisionTarget": "改局部饱满蓄水重心，滴根短厚，别扩大浪头或改接水碗"
            },
            {
              "type": "材质执行",
              "location": "上胸至下腹和额顶",
              "problem": "蓝白渐变像喷涂，长白亮带抢眼",
              "revisionTarget": "以有体积依据的少量软亮暗解释同一身体，压低白亮带"
            },
            {
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "location": "全身和滴端",
              "problem": "场景与小尺寸未验证",
              "revisionTarget": "补原岛同体量和48px，优先局部轮廓而非放大角色"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "首轮基线已评，待修订及场景证据",
          "designStatus": "历史过程图，保留对照",
          "comparison": "",
          "sceneEvidence": "未附当前版本场景结论",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "未附当前版本小尺寸结论",
          "source": "01_首轮评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "C01",
          "branch": "C",
          "name": "兜住一滴水",
          "version": "v3",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/c01-v3-1307ca6a77.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/c01-v3-1307ca6a77-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "兜住一滴将落未落的水：表面张力形成偏心水囊，目光和抿嘴一起表达专注。",
          "versionNote": "表面张力与偏心蓄水；润亮圆顶、柔哑长躯干、红橡胶靴；双眼共同上望。",
          "total": 82,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 23,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "顶部由横弧转局部水囊更简洁"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 17,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "共同上望与偏嘴成立，比旧版更专注"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 17,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "局部鼓起挂滴清楚，仍有卖萌静态"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "长白亮带降低，体积软面增强，仍无场景；附件：已实看生成场景：原构图接近，背景UI重绘，角色滴端与目光弱化、形态漂移，不证明v3精确原模型适配。"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "原长身保留，滴端小尺度制作未验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "原岛局部替换区",
              "type": "场景执行偏差",
              "problem": "已看锁背景局部版与放大并排：矩形内部建筑/草地接缝，脸目光及头囊滴端偏离主体。外区保持不抵消内区错误，场景仍不通过；上轮未因场景加分，主体总82不变。",
              "revisionTarget": "仅修角色/必要接触处；保建筑草地连续，角色形态与主体一致；若当前工具做不到，就明确保留为无可信场景，停止反复整张生成。"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "主体已评82_新轮廓场景已复核_保留收敛",
          "comparison": "78→82；局部水囊、亮带控制与身体体积均有改善，三项中的场景尚未完成。",
          "sceneEvidence": "已看等高轮廓替换：建筑已恢复，不沿用旧建筑错位判定；当前约原高度但2D缩放不等于3D相机。眼方向/头囊滴端与主体仍弱化，选中圈增厚粗边、草纹软化。场景有限；主体82保持，停止用草地补丁反复生成整身。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "已看等高轮廓替换：建筑已恢复，不沿用旧建筑错位判定；当前约原高度但2D缩放不等于3D相机。眼方向/头囊滴端与主体仍弱化，选中圈增厚粗边、草纹软化。场景有限；主体82保持，停止用草地补丁反复生成整身。",
          "smallEvidence": "48px并置已看：眼与靴可读，小悬滴极弱，局部囊形比表情更有用。",
          "source": "03_定向修订复评评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/c01-scene-3018d36955.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/c01-scene-3018d36955-preview.webp",
                "width": 1080,
                "height": 2390
              },
              "note": "已看等高轮廓替换：建筑已恢复，不沿用旧建筑错位判定；当前约原高度但2D缩放不等于3D相机。眼方向/头囊滴端与主体仍弱化，选中圈增厚粗边、草纹软化。场景有限；主体82保持，停止用草地补丁反复生成整身。"
            },
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/c01-small-4269916bdd.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/c01-small-4269916bdd-preview.webp",
                "width": 720,
                "height": 400
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "C02",
      "branch": "C",
      "name": "吸饱雨",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "C02",
          "branch": "C",
          "name": "吸饱雨",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/c02-v1-2faf3e3a7b.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/c02-v1-2faf3e3a7b-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "吸饱雨的软体：暖杏细孔身体与蓝水肢端相接，用压褶与忍住的表情表现吸水。",
          "versionNote": "水吸收为核心，暖杏细孔软体与蓝水肢端，顶侧压褶，认真忍住神态，臂自然下放",
          "total": 72,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 20,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "杏蓝清楚，细孔铺得过满"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "单眼眯配平嘴显不悦"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "海绵吸水与水端可读，头水像帽"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "粗糙海绵与亮水差大，无岛验证"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "长身和短腿保留，小五官远看偏弱"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "眼嘴",
              "type": "神态",
              "problem": "像嫌弃或不舒服",
              "revisionTarget": "减少单眼挤压，给一个明确忍住水的共同注意目标，嘴稍带意图而非苦相"
            },
            {
              "location": "表面/顶水",
              "type": "材料概念",
              "problem": "均质海绵粒和蓝帽分部感强",
              "revisionTarget": "粗孔少量分区，顶水沿压褶连续渗入，不加新道具"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "细孔五官及水掌未验",
              "revisionTarget": "补原岛48px，检查小脸识别和材质密度"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "有依据淘汰_已评72分",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px并置已看：杏软体蓝肢端能辨，忍住表情弱。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "C03",
      "branch": "C",
      "name": "溪水倔石",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "C03",
          "branch": "C",
          "name": "溪水倔石",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/c03-v1-1b97ea74ff.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/c03-v1-1b97ea74ff-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水绕过倔石：暖灰哑光石体与贴体宽水带，单侧水手试探着招手。",
          "versionNote": "",
          "total": 78,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "暖灰与青水宽S带整合清楚"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 14,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "举臂有试探，半闭眼更像困倦"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 17,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "绕石水带贯通到手足，直接可见"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "粗石与水职责清楚，无原岛；附件：已实看生成场景：暖石青水大面与原构图体量有有限参考；背景UI和脸有重绘，不验精确相机模型。"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续长身与大分材面适合缩小预判，未实测"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "眼睑",
              "type": "神态",
              "problem": "困倦强于倔强和试探",
              "revisionTarget": "抬睑保侧看，轻调嘴角与举手目标一致，别增加眉脸零件"
            },
            {
              "location": "水带边/石身",
              "type": "概念执行",
              "problem": "边界略像整齐双色浇注",
              "revisionTarget": "局部薄厚与贴绕压迫关系更自然，保持大S带而非增加纹理"
            },
            {
              "location": "场景与实际体量",
              "type": "证据限制",
              "problem": "已实看生成场景：暖石青水大面与原构图体量有有限参考；背景UI和脸有重绘，不验精确相机模型。",
              "revisionTarget": "保留已有附件；补角色不漂移、同原背景/机位的核验，检查接地、厚度与原方案特征，不重复声称完全未做。"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "历史过程图，保留对照",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "已实看生成场景：暖石青水大面与原构图体量有有限参考；背景UI和脸有重绘，不验精确相机模型。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px并置已看：宽S水带灰石与举臂可辨，眼睑语义丢失。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/c03-scene-add6038bf3.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/c03-scene-add6038bf3-preview.webp",
                "width": 843,
                "height": 1866
              },
              "note": "已实看生成场景：暖石青水大面与原构图体量有有限参考；背景UI和脸有重绘，不验精确相机模型。"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "C03",
          "branch": "C",
          "name": "溪水倔石",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/c03-v2-9893501703.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/c03-v2-9893501703-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水绕过倔石：暖灰哑光石体与贴体宽水带，单侧水手试探着招手。",
          "versionNote": "",
          "total": 79,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "高光减少、S水带更平顺"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "去厚睡眼睑，但小窄眼略呆"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 17,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水绕石和举手关系仍明确"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "镜面白带降低，水仍有体积，无新场景时不继承v1"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "宽分材保持，窄眼小尺寸风险"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "双眼",
              "type": "执行取舍",
              "problem": "由厚困睑改成窄孔，仍未清醒有主见",
              "revisionTarget": "只适度增加竖向开度，保平上缘及共同看举掌，不加眉睫"
            },
            {
              "location": "水带边",
              "type": "材料",
              "problem": "边界仍略像双色浇注",
              "revisionTarget": "局部变厚薄与贴绕感，保宽S大面，不增纹"
            },
            {
              "location": "场景/48px",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "新版本不能继承旧生成图验收",
              "revisionTarget": "补当前版附件核眼开度、体量与水带映射"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已复评，按实际缺口修订/保留或停止；非终审",
          "designStatus": "历史过程图，保留对照",
          "comparison": "v1 78→v2 79；高光与睑形有减法，清醒神态尚未充分。",
          "sceneEvidence": "已看v2局部替换：暖石青水/举手大块可见，眼睛变小点，视线无法核；局部为生成，并非主体原模型落地。不继承旧版场景通过结论，材料13分含当前主体柔光与有限配色证据。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "已看v2 48px：S水带/石体与举手清楚，窄眼表情几乎不明。",
          "source": "03_定向修订复评评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/c03-scene-1ec39d397b.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/c03-scene-1ec39d397b-preview.webp",
                "width": 1080,
                "height": 2390
              },
              "note": "已看v2局部替换：暖石青水/举手大块可见，眼睛变小点，视线无法核；局部为生成，并非主体原模型落地。不继承旧版场景通过结论，材料13分含当前主体柔光与有限配色证据。"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "C03",
          "branch": "C",
          "name": "溪水倔石",
          "version": "v3",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/c03-v3-256106294d.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/c03-v3-256106294d-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水绕过倔石：暖灰哑光石体与贴体宽水带，单侧水手试探着招手。",
          "versionNote": "溪水绕石为核心，暖灰柔哑石体与贴体宽水带，单侧水手足与试探招手",
          "total": 81,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 23,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "眼开度适中后脸身关系更协调，宽S带保留"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "共同侧看举手更清醒友好，困倦感减轻"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 17,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水绕石和试探举手直接可见"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "柔石哑水组织稳定，未当前场景，不继承旧图精确验收"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续长身大色面稳，眼部细义远看需核"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "水石界面",
              "type": "保留取舍",
              "problem": "仍有双色浇注联想，但核心结构已清楚",
              "revisionTarget": "保宽S带，不要求继续造纹；交付中如实列材料表达局限。"
            },
            {
              "location": "当前版场景",
              "type": "证据范围",
              "problem": "当前v3尚无对应场景，v2局部不能验v3眼神",
              "revisionTarget": "允许本轮用v2仅作结构体量参考并标明；不再为补图重做主体。"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "建议保留v3，不继续盲生主体；二维终审待冻结",
          "designStatus": "待R复审",
          "comparison": "79→81；适当眼开度使神态、脸身协调各提升1分，建议保留v3替代v2，不继续反复改眼。",
          "sceneEvidence": "当前v3无场景，已看v2局部仅作保留的水带/石体位置参考，不验v3表情。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "已看v2/v3 48px并置：v3开眼稍清楚，但小表情语义仍弱；宽S带/举手稳定。",
          "source": "03_定向修订复评评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/c03-small-ca6ee734c3.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/c03-small-ca6ee734c3-preview.webp",
                "width": 480,
                "height": 380
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "D01",
      "branch": "D",
      "name": "洇醒",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "D01",
          "branch": "D",
          "name": "D01",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/d01-v1-c03f7b41dd.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/d01-v1-c03f7b41dd-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "吸水纤维与湿花瓣：水的重量让花瓣低垂，头顶材料变化与共同上望相遇。",
          "versionNote": "",
          "total": null,
          "scores": [],
          "issues": [],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "未找到该图的统一 R 评分，待评",
          "designStatus": "历史过程图，保留对照",
          "comparison": "",
          "sceneEvidence": "",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "",
          "source": null,
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "D01",
          "branch": "D",
          "name": "洇醒",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/d01-v2-564026f565.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/d01-v2-564026f565-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "吸水纤维与湿花瓣：水的重量让花瓣低垂，头顶材料变化与共同上望相遇。",
          "versionNote": "吸水纤维身体、湿花瓣带珠与共同上望；材料作用和神态在同一湿瓣相遇。",
          "total": 73,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 21,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "大色面清楚，暖点分散"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "上望湿瓣挂珠，短嘴有关注"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 14,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "湿瓣可读，主体花纸吸水不明"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "花纸水体不同，身体树脂感，无原岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "主体识别稳，细花滴与纤维未测"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "type": "材料概念/执行",
              "location": "躯干过渡和白花瓣",
              "problem": "主体仍像树脂渐变，纸纤维因果弱",
              "revisionTarget": "少量同源压实纤维和软湿边，减少随机纸褶，禁止纸裤分界"
            },
            {
              "type": "识别风险",
              "location": "湿瓣与挂珠",
              "problem": "核心想法依赖很小的挂珠",
              "revisionTarget": "明确湿瓣厚薄与轻垂重心，藏珠仍能读出状态，不放大整花"
            },
            {
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "location": "全身及暖色点",
              "problem": "无原岛与48px证据",
              "revisionTarget": "同镜头同体量测试，控制高光和暖色点主次"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "首轮基线已评，待修订及场景证据",
          "designStatus": "已独立首评73_历史备用_本轮不继续",
          "comparison": "",
          "sceneEvidence": "未附当前版本场景结论",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "未附当前版本小尺寸结论",
          "source": "01_首轮评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "D01",
          "branch": "D",
          "name": "洇醒",
          "version": "v3",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/d01-v3-9c647c427a.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/d01-v3-9c647c427a-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "吸水纤维与湿花瓣：水的重量让花瓣低垂，头顶材料变化与共同上望相遇。",
          "versionNote": "回应R首评：三处宽浅压实形、加重湿瓣、减暖色分散与高光。",
          "total": 68,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 19,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "暖点减少，但身体三处裂口破坏完整"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "仍共同上望，注意目标成立"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "纸感增强却像受损纸壳"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 9,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "满身纸纹与裂口压过水感，无岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续长身保留，折裂小尺寸容易成噪声"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "胸腹折痕",
              "type": "执行偏差",
              "problem": "三处浅形生成为裂口伤痕",
              "revisionTarget": "撤掉具清晰开口和阴影的裂口，仅保宽浅湿度过渡"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身纸纹",
              "type": "材料",
              "problem": "纸纹铺满，水感大幅减弱",
              "revisionTarget": "回到v2大面，仅局部同源纤维，不再全身增加压纹"
            },
            {
              "location": "湿瓣/场景",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "湿瓣仍依赖小滴，无场景",
              "revisionTarget": "先修执行退步，再补湿瓣厚薄和原岛，不沿用v2得分"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "已独立复审68_停止使用_保留失败对照",
          "comparison": "73→68；湿纸可读性增加，但裂口、过密纸纹导致整体退步，建议以v2作修改起点而非继续叠纹。",
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "未附当前版本小尺寸结论",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "D02",
      "branch": "D",
      "name": "檐雨",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "D02",
          "branch": "D",
          "name": "檐雨",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/d02-v1-508bdf7606.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/d02-v1-508bdf7606-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "叶檐承托雨水：单叶折檐压住水顶，侧目小笑、自然下放短臂与裸水足。",
          "versionNote": "单叶折檐压水顶、后侧连续叶面、自然下垂短臂、侧目小笑与裸水足；从花纸吸水转为叶水接触承托。",
          "total": 78,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "叶檐与长身简洁，帽檐略过大"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "侧眼小笑松弛，有性格"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "叶承水关系可猜，主体偏实心"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "叶哑身润职责明确，场景仅有限合成证据"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续纵长、短臂下放成立，面部远景不清"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "叶檐/后叶",
              "type": "形体主次",
              "problem": "叶帽大且像宽布帽",
              "revisionTarget": "收檐占幅，让单叶折弯与承水压点可见，避免加叶脉"
            },
            {
              "location": "蓝身体",
              "type": "概念",
              "problem": "像蓝陶体，水感过弱",
              "revisionTarget": "只在薄端与局部体积增强水的透润关系，不整身玻璃化"
            },
            {
              "location": "场景",
              "type": "证据可信度",
              "problem": "合成沿原构图但背景UI重绘，不能证明原像素/相机精确保持",
              "revisionTarget": "提交保原图的角色区域局部替换或真实模型同机位；标注当前仅近似合成，核体量及48px"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "已独立首评78_已定向修改v2",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "已实看生成合成：构图近原岛、角色位置接近；树木/界面等有重绘，角色朝向与主体图不同，证据有限，适配未通过。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "未附当前版本小尺寸结论",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/d02-scene-7b4c2071ca.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/d02-scene-7b4c2071ca-preview.webp",
                "width": 843,
                "height": 1866
              },
              "note": "已实看生成合成：构图近原岛、角色位置接近；树木/界面等有重绘，角色朝向与主体图不同，证据有限，适配未通过。"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "D02",
          "branch": "D",
          "name": "檐雨",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/d02-v2-0ea6edf786.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/d02-v2-0ea6edf786-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "叶檐承托雨水：单叶折檐压住水顶，侧目小笑、自然下放短臂与裸水足。",
          "versionNote": "定向修订：叶檐收幅、接触压点、薄端透润，保侧目与连续长身。",
          "total": 81,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 23,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "叶檐收小后顶与长身更一体"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "侧眼小笑有松弛，神态基本稳定"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "叶压顶与水端厚薄更清楚，仍像帽但核心关系改善"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 14,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "掌足透润增强，当前原岛有有限同体量证据；非真实模型"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续长身短臂低腿保持，叶檐和大分面可辨，生产未验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "身体/水端",
              "type": "保留取舍",
              "problem": "主体仍有蓝陶或树脂感，水更多集中于掌足",
              "revisionTarget": "不要求再生成整身；保现大面，后续实际材质验证时优先少量薄端透润，避免恢复强玻璃反光。"
            },
            {
              "location": "原岛当前场景",
              "type": "证据限制",
              "problem": "当前为生成局部背面，不能验证正面侧眼与叶压顶接触的精确落地",
              "revisionTarget": "终审明确只验证大体量和配色，补同候选可对照角度/原背景接触；若暂无真模型如实保留，不反复重画背景。"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已复评，主体可收敛保留；场景证据有限，非终审",
          "designStatus": "待同一R独立复审",
          "comparison": "78→81；叶檐收小、接触压点与水端透润改善，主体可进入收敛比较，不要求无目的再改形。",
          "sceneEvidence": "已看当前局部场景：原体量近似，叶背与蓝水长身可辨；背面不能验正面侧目，选择圈右侧断接/突起和底边贴补仍有瑕疵。第4项14来自主体水端改善及有限大色块证据，不是外区0自动加分。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "已看本版48px：叶帽/蓝身/下臂可辨，掀檐侧眼与接触压点弱。",
          "source": "03_定向修订复评评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/d02-scene-aa337007b3.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/d02-scene-aa337007b3-preview.webp",
                "width": 1080,
                "height": 2390
              },
              "note": "已看当前局部场景：原体量近似，叶背与蓝水长身可辨；背面不能验正面侧目，选择圈右侧断接/突起和底边贴补仍有瑕疵。第4项14来自主体水端改善及有限大色块证据，不是外区0自动加分。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "D03",
      "branch": "D",
      "name": "回弹",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "D03",
          "branch": "D",
          "name": "回弹",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/d03-v1-ae0068fae3.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/d03-v1-ae0068fae3-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "水与天然海绵互渗：浅凹、回拱的头形和细孔软体，表现蓄水后的弹性。",
          "versionNote": "水与天然海绵纵向互渗；一体浅凹与回拱头形；有主见直视；与D01上下纸纤维和D02折檐侧目不同",
          "total": 76,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 21,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "侧海绵与水连贯，蜂窝孔和焦散过密"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "斜上眼缘有主见，略凶"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水海绵相互渗可见，回弹凹顶清楚"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "大孔与满焦散像写实材质拼接，无原岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续长身，单侧大分面可识，纹理未测"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "海绵孔/焦散",
              "type": "材料执行",
              "problem": "孔太深密、满水纹抢脸",
              "revisionTarget": "浅化并概括孔，撤大部分焦散，只留水厚薄"
            },
            {
              "location": "双眼",
              "type": "神态",
              "problem": "斜压眼缘稍凶",
              "revisionTarget": "减尖角保有主见，双眼共同明确目标，不改圆眼展示笑"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "无原岛48px",
              "revisionTarget": "先保主分面，补同体量场景及缩小证据"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "已独立首评76_备用_本轮不追修",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "未附当前版本小尺寸结论",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "D03",
          "branch": "D",
          "name": "回弹",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/d03-v2-88d2d52823.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/d03-v2-88d2d52823-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "水与天然海绵互渗：浅凹、回拱的头形和细孔软体，表现蓄水后的弹性。",
          "versionNote": "一次定向修订：海绵细孔浅色、水焦散减弱；眼缘改得过圆，神态鲜明度下降，未预设优于v1",
          "total": 77,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "材料更整洁，体块完整"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 14,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "圆眼微笑回到通用友善"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水海绵与凹顶仍直观"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "浅孔和水纹减法有效，无岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续比例稳，48px制作未测"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "双眼",
              "type": "修订取舍",
              "problem": "材料改善但失去v1有主见的眼神",
              "revisionTarget": "融合v1较平上缘与v2开放度，去尖凶又保角色性格"
            },
            {
              "location": "海绵过渡",
              "type": "材料",
              "problem": "侧海绵像一条软刷边",
              "revisionTarget": "用少量宽湿边和局部浅孔解释互渗，不恢复密焦散"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "场景48px缺失",
              "revisionTarget": "先补同机位原岛，检查浅孔是否必要"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "已独立首评77_备用_保留神态损失风险",
          "comparison": "v1 76→v2 77；材料净化改善，魅力下降2分；不认为所有维度都提升。",
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "未附当前版本小尺寸结论",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "E01",
      "branch": "E",
      "name": "呵花",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "E01",
          "branch": "E",
          "name": "呵花",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e01-v1-882967b9a9.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e01-v1-882967b9a9-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "向自己的冰花呵气：花、水腰和眼神围绕一条作用轴，探索相态与角色动作的结合。",
          "versionNote": "柔水主体向自己的冰花呵气；水腰兼花根关节，眼神和花嘴围绕一条作用轴。初版。",
          "total": 69,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 18,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "青红清爽，顶部密且腹峰拉重心"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "呵花有行为，半闭眼显懒"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "吹自花可读，瓣朝向与软根不准"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "薄花与身有别，全身亮，岛内未测"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 10,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "水与臂腿保留，收腰鼓腹偏离，细件未验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "type": "硬边界/执行",
              "location": "画面右侧腋下至腹部",
              "problem": "内收后独立鼓腹偏离普通E连续纵长体态",
              "revisionTarget": "撤掉外凸腹峰，恢复连续渐收躯干，提示词同步撤掉右腹鼓起"
            },
            {
              "type": "行为空间/执行",
              "location": "上睑嘴和目标瓣",
              "problem": "眼皮显懒，花较朝镜头，气息落点不足",
              "revisionTarget": "轻抬睑，花朝嘴，目标瓣与气息目光一致，保脸外空隙"
            },
            {
              "type": "附件与证据",
              "location": "拱梗尖瓣及全身",
              "problem": "顶部过密，玻璃细节与场景均未验",
              "revisionTarget": "缩短拱梗视觉占幅，概括瓣与亮边，补原岛和48px"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": true,
          "reviewStatus": "硬退回待修",
          "designStatus": "历史过程，已评，保留不覆盖",
          "comparison": "",
          "sceneEvidence": "未附当前版本场景结论",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "未附当前版本小尺寸结论",
          "source": "01_首轮评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "E01",
          "branch": "E",
          "name": "呵花",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e01-v2-267f664ecc.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e01-v2-267f664ecc-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "向自己的冰花呵气：花、水腰和眼神围绕一条作用轴，探索相态与角色动作的结合。",
          "versionNote": "柔水主体向自己的冰花呵气；水腰兼花根关节，眼神和花嘴围绕一条作用轴。本版定向压缩花弧、侧转花、减管口和疲倦感、改透光。",
          "total": 65,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 18,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "梗更小，但嘴花相连拥挤"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 14,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "双眼更开，行为被接管状破坏"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "像含住瓣而非外部呵气"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "身体简净，全身亮，无原岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 9,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "体态退回未解，细瓣连接不可当吹气"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "右腹",
              "type": "硬边界执行",
              "problem": "收腰鼓腹仍未解决",
              "revisionTarget": "恢复连续自然渐收躯干，别沿用F授权"
            },
            {
              "location": "嘴/花瓣",
              "type": "行为执行",
              "problem": "瓣尖与嘴直接连接，像吸管",
              "revisionTarget": "保明确外部空隙，花转嘴，目标瓣局部软化"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "无原岛48px",
              "revisionTarget": "处理前两项后再补实镜头，勿用文字声称呵气成功"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": true,
          "reviewStatus": "硬退回待修",
          "designStatus": "历史过程，已评，保留不覆盖",
          "comparison": "v1 69→v2 65；缩梗改善，但嘴瓣接触使核心行为退步，硬退回仍在。",
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px共享检查图已看：花嘴空隙及呵气几乎丢失；多版指同图，不认v2/v3各自验收。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "E01",
          "branch": "E",
          "name": "呵花",
          "version": "v3",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e01-v3-4b476f36a2.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e01-v3-4b476f36a2-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "向自己的冰花呵气：花、水腰和眼神围绕一条作用轴，探索相态与角色动作的结合。",
          "versionNote": "回应统一R首轮69分硬退回：去鼓腹恢复连续渐收体态，花瓣与嘴分离、无气线，压缩花梗与瓣形；保呵花动作。",
          "total": 75,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 21,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "梗简短、身体更顺，焦点减少"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "O嘴对花有意图，厚睑仍显懒"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "嘴花留空，呵气关系恢复，目标瓣稍弱"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水体柔软，仍偏统一高亮，无原岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "右腹峰已撤，长身关系恢复，薄花未测"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "眼睑/目标瓣",
              "type": "行为执行",
              "problem": "认真感弱，融圆瓣不突出",
              "revisionTarget": "轻抬睑且让双瞳精确看嘴对侧的一片软瓣，不加气弧替代"
            },
            {
              "location": "花梗/花冠",
              "type": "结构",
              "problem": "花仍略正向像风车",
              "revisionTarget": "微转朝嘴，保持空隙和短梗，不继续放大冰花"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "缺原岛48px",
              "revisionTarget": "补可信同机位实际体量，核花嘴空隙缩小后仍可读"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "历史过程保留；v3已获R75分、解除体态硬退回；暂转向E02/E03，不作为本路首选",
          "comparison": "v2 65→v3 75；右腹外凸撤除，嘴花空隙恢复。解除本图体态硬退回；不代表场景或终审通过。",
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px共享检查图已看：花嘴空隙及呵气几乎丢失；多版指同图，不认v2/v3各自验收。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e01-small-da21d9e721.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e01-small-da21d9e721-preview.webp",
                "width": 36,
                "height": 48
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "E02",
      "branch": "E",
      "name": "满满",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "E02",
          "branch": "E",
          "name": "满满",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e02-v1-e732ff9eb6.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e02-v1-e732ff9eb6-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "身体就是盛水器：陶体额顶嵌满水口，一侧软水臂回贴成活把手，抬眼留意水面。",
          "versionNote": "陶水身体即器形，额顶内嵌满水口及凸水面，一侧软水臂回贴成活把手，上瞄抿嘴；无原花与红靴。",
          "total": 78,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "奶白青水集中清爽，体态略上重"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "共同上瞄满口、抿嘴有稳住意图，偏担心"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 17,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "器口满水和水臂活把手关系直观"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "陶哑水亮职责明确，岛内未验；附件：已实看生成场景：满水口/奶白长身可辨；背面、UI和背景重绘，不能验正面神态、活把手与精确相机。"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "一体长体保留，活把手粘身连接与动作需验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "眼嘴",
              "type": "神态",
              "problem": "满水紧张偏担忧",
              "revisionTarget": "保上瞄和抿嘴，轻微自信而非下垂苦相"
            },
            {
              "location": "右臂把手/躯干",
              "type": "结构与比例",
              "problem": "贴身水把手有拘束感，体块略像窄肩瓶",
              "revisionTarget": "保臂根臂长，明确只是可活动触身姿态；收顺肩腹，避免固定器件化"
            },
            {
              "location": "场景与实际体量",
              "type": "证据限制",
              "problem": "已实看生成场景：满水口/奶白长身可辨；背面、UI和背景重绘，不能验正面神态、活把手与精确相机。",
              "revisionTarget": "保留已有附件；补角色不漂移、同原背景/机位的核验，检查接地、厚度与原方案特征，不重复声称完全未做。"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "已获R77分，v2已针对主要问题修订待复审",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "已实看生成场景：满水口/奶白长身可辨；背面、UI和背景重绘，不能验正面神态、活把手与精确相机。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px已看：水口与奶白体明确，活把手与上瞄弱。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e02-scene-df3ca02f3d.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e02-scene-df3ca02f3d-preview.webp",
                "width": 843,
                "height": 1866
              },
              "note": "已实看生成场景：满水口/奶白长身可辨；背面、UI和背景重绘，不能验正面神态、活把手与精确相机。"
            },
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e02-small-d33e644cf0.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e02-small-d33e644cf0-preview.webp",
                "width": 27,
                "height": 48
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "E02",
          "branch": "E",
          "name": "满满",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e02-v2-694da2d880.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e02-v2-694da2d880-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "身体就是盛水器：陶体额顶嵌满水口，一侧软水臂回贴成活把手，抬眼留意水面。",
          "versionNote": "同一概念针对统一R的主要反馈定向修订，不计新概念",
          "total": 80,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 23,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "小眼与减腮使面部更克制"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "上瞄微抿更像稳住，苦相减轻"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 17,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "满水口和活把手仍可读"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "奶白陶与青水稳定，本版场景未核，不继承旧版有限分"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续长身，右臂仍回贴但负形更简，未动作实测"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "活把手",
              "type": "结构",
              "problem": "仍可读成固定器件",
              "revisionTarget": "说明并展示同一水臂的自然活动姿态，不为区别再拉长手"
            },
            {
              "location": "眼神/水口",
              "type": "角色",
              "problem": "已改善，不需继续重做脸",
              "revisionTarget": "保持上瞄前沿和微抿，仅核实际俯视角时能否看见"
            },
            {
              "location": "场景",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "需要当前版同机位图",
              "revisionTarget": "补本版前侧/游戏视角，核杯口和活把手；避免把背面旧图当当前验收"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已复评，按实际缺口修订/保留或停止；非终审",
          "designStatus": "主体同一R80分；当前版稳定r3原岛+当前48px已由协调方交R补审；只待反馈，不重改",
          "comparison": "v1 78→v2 80；面部克制和稳住意图提升，解除担忧主观感，但结构动作还待核。",
          "sceneEvidence": "已看E02 v1原背景局部替换核查图：杯口/奶白背面可辨，但源自v1生成，不能验证v2面部与松开手端；本版sceneImage仍null，参考图单列，不冒充v2场景。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "已看v2 48px：满水口与长身明确，上瞄与活把手负形弱。",
          "source": "03_定向修订复评评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e02-scene-f93c6a1857.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e02-scene-f93c6a1857-preview.webp",
                "width": 1080,
                "height": 2390
              },
              "note": "分支新交附件，补件待评；现分数对应既有主体评审。已看E02 v1原背景局部替换核查图：杯口/奶白背面可辨，但源自v1生成，不能验证v2面部与松开手端；本版sceneImage仍null，参考图单列，不冒充v2场景。"
            },
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e02-small-2b94cce1d2.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e02-small-2b94cce1d2-preview.webp",
                "width": 660,
                "height": 430
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "E03",
      "branch": "E",
      "name": "绒泉",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "E03",
          "branch": "E",
          "name": "绒泉",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e03-v1-87cff25d5b.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e03-v1-87cff25d5b-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "湿纤维聚露：额顶绒纤维受水重下折，聚成露珠，脚末过渡为受压湿毡。",
          "versionNote": "毛细湿纤维从额顶长出并受重下折聚一颗露珠，腿末渐为受压湿毡足，水身、自然放短臂、上瞄微悦；无冰花器口靴。",
          "total": 76,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "青白清楚，头侧束与足有呼应"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "共同上望滴端亲近但通用"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "湿纤维聚滴可见，却也像白发挑染"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "纤维与水反差强，细丝与高亮未验岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "连续长身保持，头足纤维细节需缩小检验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "头侧纤维",
              "type": "概念歧义",
              "problem": "像白发而非毛细湿纤维",
              "revisionTarget": "强化短湿束的局部受重形，减发丝梳理感，不扩大成发冠"
            },
            {
              "location": "足与躯干",
              "type": "材料关系",
              "problem": "像毛拖鞋与透明身接缝",
              "revisionTarget": "用少量湿压过渡说明受压材质，不增加鞋结构"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "细丝滴端未验",
              "revisionTarget": "补同体量原岛48px，先验头束与滴的主次"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "已获R76分，v2已针对主要问题修订待复审",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px已看：白束与足有呼应，末滴弱。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e03-small-c2141145ff.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e03-small-c2141145ff-preview.webp",
                "width": 29,
                "height": 48
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "E03",
          "branch": "E",
          "name": "绒泉",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e03-v2-589189a747.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e03-v2-589189a747-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "湿纤维聚露：额顶绒纤维受水重下折，聚成露珠，脚末过渡为受压湿毡。",
          "versionNote": "同一概念针对统一R的主要反馈定向修订，不计新概念",
          "total": 77,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "头束更低，白色面积减少，整体简洁"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "上视滴端仍友善、性格变化不大"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "湿束沟与短厚滴连接更可读，仍像发梢"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "头足湿过渡改善但主体仍整体亮，未原岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "长身保持，单白束足端易认，微滴仍弱"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "额撮",
              "type": "概念歧义",
              "problem": "白发感降低但仍存在",
              "revisionTarget": "保一片低折湿束，避免再添加发缕，局部湿重是主形"
            },
            {
              "location": "足端",
              "type": "材料",
              "problem": "毛拖鞋感尚未消失",
              "revisionTarget": "保无鞋沿结构，用宽软受压边而非密丝说明湿毡"
            },
            {
              "location": "场景/48px",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "当前版需要独立检验",
              "revisionTarget": "补本版原岛体量与缩图，若仍主要读发型可止步保留候选"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已复评，按实际缺口修订/保留或停止；非终审",
          "designStatus": "同一R已评77；保留材料对照及未解歧义，不再追加主体",
          "comparison": "76→77；头束降幅、青白湿过渡改善，魅力提升有限。",
          "sceneEvidence": "当前版未见原岛场景，未借E02图作验证。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "已看v2 48px：低白撮与白足可见，小滴细节弱，仍容易读发型。",
          "source": "03_定向修订复评评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "小尺寸检查附件",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/e03-small-7b1f414418.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/e03-small-7b1f414418-preview.webp",
                "width": 29,
                "height": 48
              },
              "note": "以附件原始标注为准；并非引擎或量产验证。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "F01",
      "branch": "F",
      "name": "借壳",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "F01",
          "branch": "F",
          "name": "借壳",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/f01-v1-71c0ace34a.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/f01-v1-71c0ace34a-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "借一段陶壳容纳水：暖陶下半身、短陶嘴和水掌，专注接住一滴水。",
          "versionNote": "暖陶下半身与填水短陶嘴、水掌；专注接滴",
          "total": 78,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "暖陶青水清楚，斜口有体块节奏"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "低看掌上滴有目标，笑脸略通用"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水借陶壳、接滴行为直观，头翘滴似发梢"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "陶哑水亮分工好，水纹焦散过多，无场景"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "拼接按F授权允许，接口粗细与48px制作未验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "陶口/双臂",
              "type": "造型执行",
              "problem": "袖口与陶壳像普通连体衣",
              "revisionTarget": "强调陶器壁厚与斜口的受水关系，减少袖服感，不禁止分段"
            },
            {
              "location": "水头/水掌",
              "type": "材料",
              "problem": "密焦散抢脸，掌有多指细节",
              "revisionTarget": "保关键接滴动作，水纹做减法，手简成少量明确体块"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "未见原岛与动作结构验证",
              "revisionTarget": "补实际体量场景和接口动作说明，别借美化背景适配"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "暂不继续，保留对照",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px已看：暖陶蓝水分段与接滴姿态可见，细滴/陶壁不明。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "F02",
      "branch": "F",
      "name": "风缝",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "F02",
          "branch": "F",
          "name": "风缝",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/f02-v1-3e5b9c2a5a.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/f02-v1-3e5b9c2a5a-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "风穿过拼接的身体：开放折帆、独立水掌与软木脚，用空气缝连接不同材料。",
          "versionNote": "帆布身与软木脚、开放领口和缝线；轻步",
          "total": 76,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "灰绿布与水蓝克制，针脚略抢"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "招手微笑有亲和，仍像通用换装"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "缝布/软木拼接可见，风的作用不明显"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "材料分工清楚，布纹和焦散密，无原岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "F允许长袍与分段，足形/软接与布动作未验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "布身与缝线",
              "type": "概念方向",
              "problem": "像水人穿长衣，混搭想法停在换装",
              "revisionTarget": "让一处布缝和水结构产生可见作用或风撑形，别靠增加针脚说明"
            },
            {
              "location": "上半水体",
              "type": "材料",
              "problem": "焦散与高光过密",
              "revisionTarget": "压水纹留宽亮暗，让眼神和一个主形领先"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "无原岛/布身动作说明",
              "revisionTarget": "补场景与48px，再核软木足/软布连接是否好读；F不因非一体退回"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "待独立评审",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px已看v1/v2：v2开放折面浮头明确，受风和水厚度弱。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "F02",
          "branch": "F",
          "name": "风缝",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/f02-v2-7fa117b039.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/f02-v2-7fa117b039-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "风穿过拼接的身体：开放折帆、独立水掌与软木脚，用空气缝连接不同材料。",
          "versionNote": "重构封闭衣身为开放折帆、独立悬浮水掌、小深眼；空气缝可见，水脸偏薄片",
          "total": 79,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 23,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "折帆和浮水脸更简洁，造型区分鲜明"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "豆眼微笑亲近但静态，动作意图仍浅"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 17,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "开放折面与悬浮部位直接可见，比v1换衣更有想法"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水纹减法有效，水脸却像亚克力薄片，无原岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "F允许分离连接，48px轮廓可读，布折面/悬浮动作为未验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "水脸",
              "type": "材料执行",
              "problem": "平直厚边像蓝色平板",
              "revisionTarget": "保当前简洁大形，仅局部圆润厚薄/软重心体现水，不恢复焦散"
            },
            {
              "location": "折帆/浮掌",
              "type": "角色动作",
              "problem": "像静态拼装展示，风的轻步不足",
              "revisionTarget": "用一处折面受风弯与浮掌朝向建立同一动作，别增加多层片"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "有48px无原岛/动作验证",
              "revisionTarget": "补同体量原岛及部件运动约束，不以悬浮本身退回"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "R已评，保留对照",
          "comparison": "v1 76→v2 79；从衣筒到开放折帆、空气缝与豆眼形成实质重构，水材料变薄片是新风险。",
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px已看v1/v2：v2开放折面浮头明确，受风和水厚度弱。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "F02",
          "branch": "F",
          "name": "风缝",
          "version": "v3",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/f02-v3-78471c8855.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/f02-v3-78471c8855-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "风穿过拼接的身体：开放折帆、独立水掌与软木脚，用空气缝连接不同材料。",
          "versionNote": "局部水脸软弧厚薄、左下布角受风弯；浮掌方向仅部分落实",
          "total": 81,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 23,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "水脸更圆厚，折帆前角起风更自然"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 15,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "豆眼友好，静态专属性仍有限"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 18,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "开放折帆、空气缝及轻步受风更直观"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "软厚水面改善平板感，布哑木足有职责；未当前版场景核验"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "F授权悬浮连接成立，边距与动作需验证"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "豆眼/浮掌",
              "type": "角色意图",
              "problem": "仍可读为友好拼装展示，明确注意目标较弱",
              "revisionTarget": "不强制再生主体；保现脸与结构，后续一处手朝向/视线即可建立行为，别改回大眼套衣。"
            },
            {
              "location": "当前版场景/部件运动",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "悬浮间隙与布折面未在原岛实镜头核验",
              "revisionTarget": "只补当前版场景与48px，明确浮掌随身关系，避免用旧v2或美化背景替代。"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已复评，主体可收敛保留；场景证据有限，非终审",
          "designStatus": "待同一R独立复评",
          "comparison": "79→81；水脸由硬片变软厚，折帆受风与轻步更清楚，主体可保留。",
          "sceneEvidence": "已看v3原背景局部替换：浮水头、折帆与足大块存在；背面无豆眼，空气缝与手的连接在远景弱。局部地面生成/选中圈不证明3D浮动规则。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "已看本版48px：浮头、开放折帆、暖足清楚；视线/风受力语义弱。",
          "source": "03_定向修订复评评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/f02-scene-e0f8fcb846.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/f02-scene-e0f8fcb846-preview.webp",
                "width": 1080,
                "height": 2390
              },
              "note": "已看v3原背景局部替换：浮水头、折帆与足大块存在；背面无豆眼，空气缝与手的连接在远景弱。局部地面生成/选中圈不证明3D浮动规则。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "F03",
      "branch": "F",
      "name": "溪扣",
      "versions": [
        {
          "id": "F03",
          "branch": "F",
          "name": "溪扣",
          "version": "v1",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/f03-v1-c5584fb803.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/f03-v1-c5584fb803-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水扣住石头：独立石身、石掌与石脚由柔水连接，抬掌与侧眼形成动作关系。",
          "versionNote": "独立石躯干石掌石脚以水连接；侧眼抬掌",
          "total": 77,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 22,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "灰石青水材质组织清楚，石腹偏重"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "侧眼抬掌有交流目标和友好"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水连接石体手足直观，顶塞像额外附件"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 11,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水焦散强于粗石大面，无原岛"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "F允许独立石腹与连接，水颈四肢细接口动作未验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "顶塞/石躯干",
              "type": "主次",
              "problem": "顶部软木塞与石体关系弱，石腹抢重心",
              "revisionTarget": "选择是否保塞并给可见用途；石体略概括主转面，别用多纹理分散"
            },
            {
              "location": "水连接/掌",
              "type": "材料执行",
              "problem": "接口像透明管和玻璃袖，满水纹抢眼",
              "revisionTarget": "少量有厚薄的软连接，减焦散，保持石与水共同组成角色"
            },
            {
              "location": "全身",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "拼接稳定和原岛均未验证",
              "revisionTarget": "补原岛体量及接点运动说明；不因新体态本身退回"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "待独立评审",
          "comparison": null,
          "sceneEvidence": "本候选无场景证据，不判适配通过",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px已看v1/v2：灰石青连接与抬掌可辨，水材料语义弱。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": []
        },
        {
          "id": "F03",
          "branch": "F",
          "name": "溪扣",
          "version": "v2",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/f03-v2-5ddf6447d4.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/f03-v2-5ddf6447d4-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水扣住石头：独立石身、石掌与石脚由柔水连接，抬掌与侧眼形成动作关系。",
          "versionNote": "删除顶部瓶塞与粉腮气泡、收窄石身、加厚水臂；结构清楚，水材质更弱",
          "total": 80,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 23,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "撤顶塞收石身后主次更稳"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "共同抬掌注视友好，角色关系明确"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 17,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "石块与软连接清楚，水感略弱"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水纹减法显著，但水变哑树脂，场景重绘仅有限证据；附件：已实看生成场景：青水灰石背面大块可辨；背景UI重绘，仅有限参考。树脂化水感风险仍在，第4项不因交场景自动上调。"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "F开放结构成立，48px双材与动作可读，软接运动未验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "水头/水臂",
              "type": "材料执行",
              "problem": "水纹清掉后像青色树脂",
              "revisionTarget": "不回密焦散，以少量厚薄和软亮暗增强水感，保暖石哑面"
            },
            {
              "location": "石身/抬掌",
              "type": "形体节奏",
              "problem": "石体仍重，动作略拘谨",
              "revisionTarget": "保修长稳定，只微调软接弯曲与掌角产生轻动感，不新增材料"
            },
            {
              "location": "场景与实际体量",
              "type": "证据限制",
              "problem": "已实看生成场景：青水灰石背面大块可辨；背景UI重绘，仅有限参考。树脂化水感风险仍在，第4项不因交场景自动上调。",
              "revisionTarget": "保留已有附件；补角色不漂移、同原背景/机位的核验，检查接地、厚度与原方案特征，不重复声称完全未做。"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已评，待关键修订/保留或淘汰理由及复评",
          "designStatus": "R已评，保留对照",
          "comparison": "v1 77→v2 80；撤顶塞、收石体、粗水臂与删噪纹有效；保留水感不足问题。",
          "sceneEvidence": "已实看生成场景：青水灰石背面大块可辨；背景UI重绘，仅有限参考。树脂化水感风险仍在，第4项不因交场景自动上调。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "48px已看v1/v2：灰石青连接与抬掌可辨，水材料语义弱。",
          "source": "02_多方案评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/f03-scene-d3c57ac219.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/f03-scene-d3c57ac219-preview.webp",
                "width": 843,
                "height": 1866
              },
              "note": "已实看生成场景：青水灰石背面大块可辨；背景UI重绘，仅有限参考。树脂化水感风险仍在，第4项不因交场景自动上调。"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "F03",
          "branch": "F",
          "name": "溪扣",
          "version": "v3",
          "image": {
            "full": "design-review-20261107/images/f03-v3-47ba1c4901.png",
            "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/f03-v3-47ba1c4901-preview.webp",
            "width": 1024,
            "height": 1536
          },
          "concept": "溪水扣住石头：独立石身、石掌与石脚由柔水连接，抬掌与侧眼形成动作关系。",
          "versionNote": "水体薄端透润、减少树脂哑面，抬掌回落和软臂曲线微调；保长石身与两材质",
          "total": 81,
          "scores": [
            {
              "dimension": "整体美感与协调",
              "score": 23,
              "max": 25,
              "evidence": "石身与厚水连接节奏稳定，少了额外附件"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "神态与角色魅力",
              "score": 16,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "抬掌共同注意明确，清醒友好"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "核心想法与独特性",
              "score": 17,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "水接石头手足关系保持直接可见"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "材质配色与岛内适配",
              "score": 13,
              "max": 20,
              "evidence": "透边和软反光使水感较v2增强，仍灰玻璃化，无当前版场景验收"
            },
            {
              "dimension": "轮廓、小尺寸与可制作性",
              "score": 12,
              "max": 15,
              "evidence": "F允许不同体态与连接，细关节已加厚，制作待验"
            }
          ],
          "issues": [
            {
              "location": "水脸/水连接",
              "type": "保留取舍",
              "problem": "水感增强但偏灰玻璃，主体色吸引力稍弱",
              "revisionTarget": "保结构，不要求继续整张改形；实际材质中以少量青水色和软亮暗平衡，不恢复焦散。"
            },
            {
              "location": "当前版原岛",
              "type": "证据缺口",
              "problem": "旧v2整幅生成场景不能验证v3",
              "revisionTarget": "只补当前版同体量、同原背景局部证据及48px，不反复重做已成立的石水结构。"
            }
          ],
          "hardReturn": false,
          "reviewStatus": "已复评，主体可收敛保留；场景证据有限，非终审",
          "designStatus": "待同一R独立复评",
          "comparison": "80→81；透边、厚度和反光增强，水感较v2有实质改善，主体可收敛保留。",
          "sceneEvidence": "已看v3原背景局部替换：石身/水脸背面及抬掌大关系存在，同体量近似；小水臂/石掌缩得很小，局部草地接触仍生成，当前正面友好神态未核。",
          "latestSceneUpdate": "",
          "smallEvidence": "已看本版48px：石身青连接/抬掌明确，软水厚度与瞳孔细节弱。",
          "source": "03_定向修订复评评分.json",
          "attachments": [
            {
              "label": "原岛场景合成（二维参考）",
              "image": {
                "full": "design-review-20261107/images/f03-scene-86affc3fa0.png",
                "preview": "design-review-20261107/images/f03-scene-86affc3fa0-preview.webp",
                "width": 1080,
                "height": 2390
              },
              "note": "已看v3原背景局部替换：石身/水脸背面及抬掌大关系存在，同体量近似；小水臂/石掌缩得很小，局部草地接触仍生成，当前正面友好神态未核。"
            }
          ]
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}