来源标题与会议时点保留;本机文件链接改为文字。原话与整理说明按原文件分别标注。
{
"schemaVersion": "1.0",
"stage": "喇叭花同形双义纠偏轮",
"basis": "[本地来源路径]",
"sourceImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"sourceActuallyViewed": true,
"sourceEvidence": {
"instrument": "金色内腔向外张开,有厚口沿和连续弯管,躯干带有号身/共鸣腔读法;不依赖写出名字。",
"flower": "同一开口外缘由红色瓣状轮廓包围,弯曲管颈同时可读作承花茎。",
"sharedGeometry": "号口与花冠共用一次外张开口;弯管—茎—躯干共用连续路径。不是手持一把号,也不是一朵自然花插到无关物体。",
"boundaries": "用户认可此结构巧思,不等于定稿金色、亮金属、红绿紫、原五官或原鞋。无需凭空加吹口/阀键才算喇叭;但第二种读法必须可见。"
},
"coreGate": {
"required": "同一处形体同时读到人使用的喇叭与花,并有可见共享路径。",
"reject": [
"只有天然花/薄花瓣与植物茎",
"只有喇叭乐器,花读法未成立",
"花角色另外拿喇叭或二者独立并排"
],
"consequence": "本轮核心未成立;独立列为退回/不得入优选,不靠其他分项抵消。"
},
"rubric": {
"shapeCoordination": 30,
"expressionCharm": 20,
"visibleCombination": 20,
"materialColor": 15,
"smallSizeMotion": 15
},
"reviewProcedure": [
"先看图、不读说明,写第一眼身份/神态。",
"分别写喇叭读法、花读法和同一位置/路径的画面证据;不得靠候选名或文字补齐。",
"再读设计与原型,评五项并给1—2个最关键修改。",
"核心门槛未成立时标退回,不因漂亮或高分进入优选。",
"版本逐图重评,96/48与动作未验证总分暂定,旧分不转用。"
],
"historicalCandidates": {
"file": "[本地来源路径]",
"status": "历史保留;旧自然组合稿本轮核心未成立,旧85/86分不代表符合当前方向。"
},
"reviews": [
{
"candidateId": "A_P01",
"version": "v1",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"firstImpression": {
"identity": "珠灰梨形弯管人顶着深紫口、厚瓣边的花号,绿手套和绿鞋。",
"expression": "大白眼向右上、开口偏笑与托掌像在开心观察上方;未准确落到掌上。"
},
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "厚壁粗弯管从身体连续转向一个深开口,能读人用弯号;号口的窄卷唇偏弱。",
"flower": "同一开口外缘为五个浅圆瓣,管旁小叶和弯曲生长路径提供植物读法。",
"sharedGeometry": "梨形共鸣身—粗弯管—深号花口连续,同一口兼花冠;不是另插自然花。",
"status": "同形双义成立",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 25,
"expressionCharm": 17,
"visibleCombination": 17,
"materialColor": 12,
"smallSizeMotion": 11
},
"scoreEvidence": {
"shapeCoordination": "梨身、粗弯管和花号连续,稳定且有弯直节奏;花冠略压脸。",
"expressionCharm": "白眼瞳孔、开嘴和托掌有天真感,共同目标略泛。",
"visibleCombination": "双读成立,但厚瓣法兰强于外张号唇,第二读不及C_P02直接。",
"materialColor": "暖灰硬身、软绿布臂、深绿胶鞋分部明确,硬身表面仍偏柔玩偶。",
"smallSizeMotion": "96px花号深口、脸和托掌可认;48px仍有弯花号与白眼,但嘴和具体视线很弱,未验证探索神态。 无动作补件与引擎验证。"
},
"total": 82,
"totalStatus": "暂定",
"coreReturn": {
"required": false,
"reason": "两种读法共享形体,非自然花插身体或另拿乐器。"
},
"issues": [
{
"type": "生成执行偏差",
"location": "花号外沿至内腔",
"evidence": "外缘像一块厚花形法兰,中间直接挖深口;喇叭外张锥口和窄卷唇不够清楚。",
"target": "保留共享瓣缘,减少整块厚平法兰感,增强同一个号口的外张曲面/窄唇,不另贴一朵自然花。",
"verification": "同条件新旧图并排,看共享轮廓/神态是否实际改善。"
},
{
"type": "神态关系待加强",
"location": "双瞳与托掌",
"evidence": "瞳孔上看花与手之间,托掌像礼貌介绍,注意对象不够明确。",
"target": "只微调共同注视点或掌的朝向之一,选一个实际注意位置,不增加道具。",
"verification": "同条件新旧图并排,看共享轮廓/神态是否实际改善。"
}
],
"verification": {
"actualImageViewed": true,
"small96": "已实际打开绑定本版源图的真实高度96px",
"small48": "已实际打开绑定本版源图的真实高度48px",
"motion": "只观察主图姿势,动作补件与引擎未验",
"smallSizeFiles": [
"[本地来源路径]",
"[本地来源路径]"
],
"smallSizeObservation": "96px花号深口、脸和托掌可认;48px仍有弯花号与白眼,但嘴和具体视线很弱,未验证探索神态。"
},
"status": "revise",
"scoreHistory": [
{
"stage": "主图首读",
"total": 82,
"smallSizeMotion": 11
},
{
"stage": "96/48px补证",
"total": 82,
"smallSizeMotion": 11,
"reason": "96px花号深口、脸和托掌可认;48px仍有弯花号与白眼,但嘴和具体视线很弱,未验证探索神态。 首读保留的风险获证实,暂不变分。"
}
]
},
{
"candidateId": "A_P01",
"version": "v2",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"firstImpression": {
"identity": "薄壁紫色花号口从珠灰弯管梨身连续外张,厚平花瓣板基本消失。",
"expression": "瞳孔较v1向托掌方向下移,开心发现关系更明确;大白眼/大笑口仍偏通用幼态。"
},
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "可见轻薄成形的外张深喉、细卷唇和连续粗弯管,号口身份增强。",
"flower": "同一片外张薄壳的五浅瓣外缘兼花冠,不是额外贴花。",
"sharedGeometry": "薄壳边界自身兼号唇和花缘,弯管兼承花茎,连续到梨形共鸣身。",
"status": "同形双义成立,口沿整合较v1改善",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 26,
"expressionCharm": 18,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 12,
"smallSizeMotion": 11
},
"scoreEvidence": {
"shapeCoordination": "厚平法兰改为连续外张面,花口与弯管更连贯。",
"expressionCharm": "瞳孔下移贴近托掌注意方向,神态较完整;大白眼笑口仍模板化。",
"visibleCombination": "同一薄壳瓣状号唇同时承载两读,非两层花板;共享管路维持。",
"materialColor": "身/布臂/胶鞋仍可区分,硬釉身和细纹仍偏玩偶;不因口沿变薄自动提高整身材质分。",
"smallSizeMotion": "v2 96px花号深腔和脸掌可分;48px薄唇本身难辨、脸和托掌保留,具体注视没有稳定显著增益。 尺寸动作仍11,无运动补件/引擎验证。"
},
"total": 86,
"totalStatus": "暂定",
"coreReturn": {
"required": false,
"reason": "两种读法共享形体,非自然花插身体或另拿乐器。"
},
"issues": [
{
"type": "角色魅力待深化",
"location": "大白眼、眉与开嘴",
"evidence": "目光落掌改善,但眼白与大开口的组合仍是通用开心娃娃脸,个性不及形体巧思明确。",
"target": "值得只试一种眼白面积或眉口力度的微调,保住看掌行为;不整脸推翻、不套另一张默认脸。",
"verification": "同条件前后图对照;补新版真实96/48px,不套首版。"
},
{
"type": "缩小后神态未获显著增益",
"location": "48px薄唇与脸掌",
"evidence": "完整花号仍可认,但薄唇细节与具体视线弱,小尺寸神态较v1未显著提升。",
"target": "保留大图薄壳改进,不为48px再加厚口;后续按实际岛上尺度决定五官取舍。",
"verification": "后续若继续,按同一版本与实际补证核对;本轮不再新增生成。"
}
],
"verification": {
"actualImageViewed": true,
"small96": "已实际查看D绑定本版源图的96px及revision板",
"small48": "已实际查看D绑定本版源图的48px及revision板",
"motion": "仅主图迈步结构观察,未动作/引擎验证",
"smallSizeObservation": "v2 96px花号深腔和脸掌可分;48px薄唇本身难辨、脸和托掌保留,具体注视没有稳定显著增益。",
"smallSizeFiles": [
"[本地来源路径]",
"[本地来源路径]"
]
},
"status": "revise",
"scoreHistory": [
{
"stage": "v2主图初评",
"total": 86
},
{
"stage": "v2缩图补证",
"total": 86,
"reason": "v2 96px花号深腔和脸掌可分;48px薄唇本身难辨、脸和托掌保留,具体注视没有稳定显著增益。 分数不变。"
}
],
"changes": {
"fromVersion": "v1",
"fromTotal": 82,
"toTotal": 86,
"delta": 4,
"scoreDeltas": {
"shapeCoordination": 1,
"expressionCharm": 1,
"visibleCombination": 2,
"materialColor": 0,
"smallSizeMotion": 0
},
"basis": "实图薄瓣状号唇外张与目光落掌改善;未用旧v1缩图替新版验证。"
}
},
{
"candidateId": "A_P02",
"version": "v1",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"firstImpression": {
"identity": "紫色竖向环号身体,米白深号喉与五瓣卷唇,木枝臂、奶油鞋。",
"expression": "大白眼、腮红与偏笑显友好,眉带一点疑惑;前伸掌与目光联系不够明确。"
},
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "厚回管形成大环,沿上端延至深锥喉,有人用卷号的读法,不只是植物茎。",
"flower": "紫色口唇自身五浅瓣起伏,米白喉连续收拢;比外贴一圈平花瓣更融合。",
"sharedGeometry": "环体兼盘卷茎与号管,外张口唇兼瓣缘,路径连续,无独立头或手持号。",
"status": "同形双义成立",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 25,
"expressionCharm": 16,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 13,
"smallSizeMotion": 11
},
"scoreEvidence": {
"shapeCoordination": "竖向单环与号口连贯,负形清楚;环过正像数字0,个性略模板化。",
"expressionCharm": "友好表情可读,但大眼腮红/微笑/托掌组合偏通用幼态,缺独特事件。",
"visibleCombination": "同一卷唇兼浅瓣,环号管兼卷茎,双读清楚。",
"materialColor": "紫瓷/暖枝/奶油胶鞋差异有依据,木臂指掌仍厚软。",
"smallSizeMotion": "环孔、手脚姿态清楚,96/48与木腿弯折未验。"
},
"total": 84,
"totalStatus": "暂定",
"coreReturn": {
"required": false,
"reason": "具有共享口/管路径;整合弱处仍需修,不靠漂亮抵消。"
},
"issues": [
{
"type": "神态/角色表达待加强",
"location": "眼眉、腮红与托掌",
"evidence": "白大眼腮红与笑口都在卖友好,微疑惑眉和托掌未产生具体探索事件。",
"target": "保留当前环号身份,只减少一种默认幼态信号并明确视线/手指的共同目标;不把换脸当换角色。",
"verification": "新旧主图同条件对照,具体核实形体而不读解释。"
},
{
"type": "概念形体待比较",
"location": "过正的竖向环身",
"evidence": "躯干轮廓几乎是均匀数字0,上面接花号;回管的走向感与不对称生长性弱于C_P02。",
"target": "仅试一处不等管径或非正圆回弯,保住完整共享路径,勿额外堆螺旋/把环做提手。",
"verification": "新旧主图同条件对照,具体核实形体而不读解释。"
}
],
"verification": {
"actualImageViewed": true,
"small96": "待验",
"small48": "待验",
"motion": "仅主图动作观察,无动作补件和引擎验证"
},
"status": "revise"
},
{
"candidateId": "B_P01",
"version": "v1",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"firstImpression": {
"identity": "紫色长弯号身,下部像夹颚分叉,杏色五瓣围着紫号口,绿织带手臂。",
"expression": "抬眉张嘴与右手向上招呼,亲和但脸份量小,动作目的偏泛。"
},
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "圆形窄卷口、深锥喉与连续厚弯管直接读号,乐器身份明确。",
"flower": "同一号口外沿有杏色瓣状展开,口与花冠共用喉和外张承接。",
"sharedGeometry": "共鸣长梨身连续到弯管与号花口;下端夹颚也用本体体块,没有另背夹子。 复看可见紫色完整圆唇前后与杏瓣平面叠接,整合仍弱;共享的是喉口,不是已实现单一瓣状号唇。",
"status": "双读基本成立,口沿两圈整合偏弱",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 24,
"expressionCharm": 16,
"visibleCombination": 18,
"materialColor": 12,
"smallSizeMotion": 9
},
"scoreEvidence": {
"shapeCoordination": "长梨与弯管连续,纤臂轻;长裸颈和大口使小脸偏下。",
"expressionCharm": "小开嘴与上抬眉有亲和,注意目标不够强。",
"visibleCombination": "号/花同口成立,夹颚只见下叉,前后夹持关系较弱。",
"materialColor": "紫身与紫胶鞋呼应,绿织带臂独立;硬陶身与胶鞋反差弱。",
"smallSizeMotion": "96px长颈、双圈花号和夹颚可认,脸较小;48px眼口近乎消失,下叉更像裤裆,人物神态最弱。 无动作补件与引擎验证。"
},
"total": 79,
"totalStatus": "暂定",
"coreReturn": {
"required": false,
"reason": "两种读法共享形体,非自然花插身体或另拿乐器。"
},
"issues": [
{
"type": "核心整合/比例待调整",
"location": "紫色圆号唇、杏瓣平面及长颈",
"evidence": "圆唇闭环完整,杏瓣另作平面,二圈拼接明显;长颈使小脸偏下。双读存在,但巧思仍偏拆件。",
"target": "先让号唇自身兼瓣缘、保深喉粗管;长颈比例列后续,不一轮同时重做全身。",
"verification": "无说明看是否仍读两圈物件;不以有花瓣又有号口直接宣布整合充分。"
},
{
"type": "第三原型转译未完全落实",
"location": "下腹夹颚槽与体片",
"evidence": "下部只有相向分叉和一个缝,第一眼更像分叉衣摆/两腿,前后颚承托关系没有显示。",
"target": "用厚薄/前后错位把夹颚融成本体接合,先补一个局部角度,不添加弹簧道具堆。",
"verification": "同条件新旧图并排,看共享轮廓/神态是否实际改善。"
}
],
"verification": {
"actualImageViewed": true,
"small96": "已实际打开绑定本版源图的真实高度96px",
"small48": "已实际打开绑定本版源图的真实高度48px",
"motion": "只观察主图姿势,动作补件与引擎未验",
"smallSizeFiles": [
"[本地来源路径]",
"[本地来源路径]"
],
"smallSizeObservation": "96px长颈、双圈花号和夹颚可认,脸较小;48px眼口近乎消失,下叉更像裤裆,人物神态最弱。"
},
"status": "revise",
"scoreHistory": [
{
"stage": "主图首读",
"total": 80,
"smallSizeMotion": 10
},
{
"stage": "96/48px补证",
"total": 79,
"smallSizeMotion": 9,
"reason": "96px长颈、双圈花号和夹颚可认,脸较小;48px眼口近乎消失,下叉更像裤裆,人物神态最弱。 尺寸动作10→9,其他分不变。"
}
]
},
{
"candidateId": "B_P01",
"version": "v2",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"firstImpression": {
"identity": "同一紫长弯号身体,杏紫渐变的五浅瓣薄壳口成为一个外张面。",
"expression": "小眼张嘴和托掌保留,仍偏泛招呼,脸与长颈比例未变。"
},
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "连续深喉、细卷唇和粗弯管读号;不是完整圆环再贴花板。",
"flower": "号唇自身五浅瓣,杏紫渐变沿同一壳面展开成花冠。",
"sharedGeometry": "同一外张面兼号口与花冠,弯管/号身兼植物路径;夹颚仍像下叉。",
"status": "同形双义成立,口沿两圈问题已改善",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 25,
"expressionCharm": 16,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 12,
"smallSizeMotion": 9
},
"scoreEvidence": {
"shapeCoordination": "双圈改为一个连续外张面,头顶关系更协调;长颈小脸仍在。",
"expressionCharm": "原小脸/表情和托掌基本保留,未新增明确注意事件。",
"visibleCombination": "两读共享同一瓣状号唇,较首版整合更好;下夹颚转译仍弱。",
"materialColor": "硬身/织带臂/胶鞋大分部保留,身面仍有细纹和柔玩偶感。",
"smallSizeMotion": "新图未有独立缩图,但小脸/长颈/下叉结构基本未改,按当前静态风险9,不将旧缩图称本版测试。"
},
"total": 81,
"totalStatus": "暂定",
"coreReturn": {
"required": false,
"reason": "两种读法共享形体,非自然花插身体或另拿乐器。"
},
"issues": [
{
"type": "第三原型执行偏差",
"location": "下腹夹颚",
"evidence": "加了一点厚边和深度,但正面仍强烈像裤裆,两片前后相向颚关系未读清。",
"target": "本轮不再精修;若选此概念,先以真正侧角结构证明夹持接合,别加弹簧道具。",
"verification": "后续若继续,按同一版本与实际补证核对;本轮不再新增生成。"
},
{
"type": "概念比例/神态",
"location": "长颈与小脸",
"evidence": "共享花号改善,但人物脸仍小、托掌泛招呼,角色魅力未同步改善。",
"target": "若后续选此路,只缩裸颈或提高脸份量之一,另明确一个注意目标。",
"verification": "后续若继续,按同一版本与实际补证核对;本轮不再新增生成。"
}
],
"verification": {
"actualImageViewed": true,
"small96": "v2未单独实测",
"small48": "v2未单独实测",
"motion": "仅主图步态,未验证动作/引擎"
},
"status": "revise",
"scoreHistory": [],
"changes": {
"fromVersion": "v1",
"fromTotal": 79,
"toTotal": 81,
"delta": 2,
"scoreDeltas": {
"shapeCoordination": 1,
"expressionCharm": 0,
"visibleCombination": 1,
"materialColor": 0,
"smallSizeMotion": 0
},
"basis": "实际单层薄壳口取代圆环叠瓣,造型/核心各+1;夹颚仍弱,不因修改指令有两项就给两项通过。"
}
},
{
"candidateId": "B_P02",
"version": "v1",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"firstImpression": {
"identity": "灰青横向带孔壶状回管,左上花号,木Y腿托与红鞋、米色织带臂。",
"expression": "平眉小笑、双掌摊开,像在说明或迎接;坚定试探的前伸动作较弱。"
},
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "粗管回弯通向外张深号喉,能有号角读法;但横腹带孔更先像提壶/浇水壶,号身身份偏弱。",
"flower": "紫色花形外缘与米白号喉共用同一开口,但完整圆口加平瓣边层叠感明显。",
"sharedGeometry": "同一回管/茎通向花号,未另拿道具;然而壶状腹与双圈口让共形巧思被拆件感削弱。",
"status": "双读基本成立,乐器读法及口沿整合偏弱",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 23,
"expressionCharm": 15,
"visibleCombination": 16,
"materialColor": 12,
"smallSizeMotion": 10
},
"scoreEvidence": {
"shapeCoordination": "横向粗回管与Y托有承重关系,但宽腹更像壶身;口、腹、腿各一块。",
"expressionCharm": "平眉小笑与摊手较温和泛用,缺少明确尝试动作。",
"visibleCombination": "共享口与管存在,不能称核心完全缺失;但初眼提壶与两圈叠接削弱直接双读。",
"materialColor": "灰青硬身、米织带、棕托红胶鞋区分清楚,织臂细纹密、硬身略塑料。",
"smallSizeMotion": "宽体稳脚可见,手掌与回孔关系复杂;96/48及托腿运动待验。"
},
"total": 76,
"totalStatus": "暂定",
"coreReturn": {
"required": false,
"reason": "具有共享口/管路径;整合弱处仍需修,不靠漂亮抵消。"
},
"issues": [
{
"type": "核心读法整合待加强",
"location": "横腹回管及侧孔",
"evidence": "圆鼓宽腹的孔像提手而不是回号负形,第一眼容易读为浇水壶,喇叭身份比其他P稿弱。",
"target": "降低实心壶腹感,明确一条回返管路及其负形,保留Y托;不加号键/吹嘴零件来遮盖整体问题。",
"verification": "新旧主图同条件对照,具体核实形体而不读解释。"
},
{
"type": "生成执行偏差/核心边界",
"location": "紫平瓣缘与米白圆号唇",
"evidence": "完整米白圆口前套一层紫花形板,读作两圈拼接,花瓣没参与号唇本身的起伏。",
"target": "让同一号唇兼五浅瓣,保留深喉外张;减少平花板层,不另做真实花。",
"verification": "新旧主图同条件对照,具体核实形体而不读解释。"
}
],
"verification": {
"actualImageViewed": true,
"small96": "待验",
"small48": "待验",
"motion": "仅主图动作观察,无动作补件和引擎验证"
},
"status": "revise"
},
{
"candidateId": "C_P01",
"version": "v1",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"firstImpression": {
"identity": "灰绿S形花号人,珊瑚瓣缘与深杯口,纤维臂、紫腿鞋和侧边叶芽小吹口。",
"expression": "白眼上看花号口,抬掌接近号口,张嘴像好奇侧听;比泛招手更有共同对象。"
},
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "深杯状号腔、厚口沿、通长S曲管与下部共鸣腹连通,右下小开口补号身读法。",
"flower": "珊瑚瓣缘与同一外张杯口共形,S曲管也像生长花茎,末端带叶芽。",
"sharedGeometry": "一条连续S路径兼号管/植物茎,花冠与号口完全共喉,不是另拿号。",
"status": "同形双义成立",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 25,
"expressionCharm": 17,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 13,
"smallSizeMotion": 11
},
"scoreEvidence": {
"shapeCoordination": "S曲线有明确动势,共鸣腹与细腰有节奏;脸在上部、腿在下部距离较长。",
"expressionCharm": "眼睛、近口抬掌与张嘴共同侧听;大眼腮红略模板化但不构成硬错。",
"visibleCombination": "深口/瓣缘与连续号管/茎双读直接,叶芽吹口为同体补充而非道具。",
"materialColor": "灰绿身、珊瑚花缘、麦臂紫胶鞋有清楚面积分工,宽明暗仍有轻微颗粒。",
"smallSizeMotion": "96pxS共享曲管与抬手看口关系尚可读;48px眼神/嘴消失,薄臂与叶芽吹口变小点,S号轮廓仍在。 无动作补件与引擎验证。"
},
"total": 85,
"totalStatus": "暂定",
"coreReturn": {
"required": false,
"reason": "两种读法共享形体,非自然花插身体或另拿乐器。"
},
"issues": [
{
"type": "比例/结构待比较",
"location": "S腰、共鸣腹与肩臂接点",
"evidence": "脸在S曲上段,双臂接在较细颈腰附近,与下部膨大腹和腿分离,容易像长柄身体。",
"target": "做一个仅缩短中腰或稍上提腹体的受控对照,保留S管和侧听神态,勿拉直成普通梨身。",
"verification": "同条件新旧图并排,看共享轮廓/神态是否实际改善。"
},
{
"type": "材料执行偏差",
"location": "号身和纤维臂表面",
"evidence": "均带细密颗粒/纤维描写,仍有照片玩具感;上肢靠绞纹区分过多。",
"target": "减少微纹,以大曲面硬身与柔性臂的折转、厚薄维持材料差,保留深号喉。",
"verification": "同条件新旧图并排,看共享轮廓/神态是否实际改善。"
}
],
"verification": {
"actualImageViewed": true,
"small96": "已实际打开绑定本版源图的真实高度96px",
"small48": "已实际打开绑定本版源图的真实高度48px",
"motion": "只观察主图姿势,动作补件与引擎未验",
"smallSizeFiles": [
"[本地来源路径]",
"[本地来源路径]"
],
"smallSizeObservation": "96pxS共享曲管与抬手看口关系尚可读;48px眼神/嘴消失,薄臂与叶芽吹口变小点,S号轮廓仍在。"
},
"status": "revise",
"scoreHistory": [
{
"stage": "主图首读",
"total": 85,
"smallSizeMotion": 11
},
{
"stage": "96/48px补证",
"total": 85,
"smallSizeMotion": 11,
"reason": "96pxS共享曲管与抬手看口关系尚可读;48px眼神/嘴消失,薄臂与叶芽吹口变小点,S号轮廓仍在。 首读保留的风险获证实,暂不变分。"
}
]
},
{
"candidateId": "C_P01",
"version": "v2",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"firstImpression": {
"identity": "同一S曲花号人,中腰更充实、腹体稍上移,细绞纹消失,长姿态仍保留。",
"expression": "眼睛、张口、抬手近号口的侧听事件保留,神态没有因简化变弱。"
},
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "深杯状号腔、厚口沿、通长S曲管与下部共鸣腹连通,右下小开口补号身读法。",
"flower": "珊瑚瓣缘与同一外张杯口共形,S曲管也像生长花茎,末端带叶芽。",
"sharedGeometry": "一条连续S路径兼号管/植物茎,花冠与号口完全共喉,不是另拿号。",
"status": "同形双义成立",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 26,
"expressionCharm": 17,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 13,
"smallSizeMotion": 11
},
"scoreEvidence": {
"shapeCoordination": "腰段收紧并增厚,腹体向上,使肩腹较接近;长S曲动势仍在。",
"expressionCharm": "眼睛、近口抬掌与张嘴共同侧听;大眼腮红略模板化但不构成硬错。",
"visibleCombination": "深口/瓣缘与连续号管/茎双读直接,叶芽吹口为同体补充而非道具。",
"materialColor": "微纹/纤维消失,2.5D信息更简洁;臂也变光滑软管,身臂触感差别仍不充分,所以材质维持13。",
"smallSizeMotion": "v2 96px腰腹更连贯,侧听与近口手尚可读;48px与v1相近,25px左右横宽限制微表情,不能夸大成识别跃升。 尺寸动作仍11,无运动补件/引擎验证。"
},
"total": 86,
"totalStatus": "暂定",
"coreReturn": {
"required": false,
"reason": "两种读法共享形体,非自然花插身体或另拿乐器。"
},
"issues": [
{
"type": "材料执行偏差/取舍",
"location": "光滑手臂与共鸣身",
"evidence": "降纹成功,但麦色臂从绞纤维变成光滑软管,身与臂都柔哑;区别主要靠颜色和粗细。",
"target": "若继续改,仅用弯折/压扁边或简洁纤维带结构显柔性,身保硬质大曲面,勿加回细绳纹。",
"verification": "同条件前后图对照;补新版真实96/48px,不套首版。"
},
{
"type": "号口材料待比较",
"location": "珊瑚瓣缘",
"evidence": "珊瑚瓣缘仍厚鼓,较像充气花瓣而非轻薄号壳的五浅瓣卷唇。",
"target": "试一版仅压薄瓣缘实体、保留深喉和S身份,不把整花拉成写实薄花。",
"verification": "同条件前后图对照;补新版真实96/48px,不套首版。"
}
],
"verification": {
"actualImageViewed": true,
"small96": "已实际查看D绑定本版源图的96px及revision板",
"small48": "已实际查看D绑定本版源图的48px及revision板",
"motion": "只看主图侧听/步态,动作与引擎未验",
"smallSizeObservation": "v2 96px腰腹更连贯,侧听与近口手尚可读;48px与v1相近,25px左右横宽限制微表情,不能夸大成识别跃升。",
"smallSizeFiles": [
"[本地来源路径]",
"[本地来源路径]"
]
},
"status": "revise",
"scoreHistory": [
{
"stage": "v2主图初评",
"total": 86
},
{
"stage": "v2缩图补证",
"total": 86,
"reason": "v2 96px腰腹更连贯,侧听与近口手尚可读;48px与v1相近,25px左右横宽限制微表情,不能夸大成识别跃升。 分数不变。"
}
],
"changes": {
"fromVersion": "v1",
"fromTotal": 85,
"toTotal": 86,
"delta": 1,
"scoreDeltas": {
"shapeCoordination": 1,
"expressionCharm": 0,
"visibleCombination": 0,
"materialColor": 0,
"smallSizeMotion": 0
},
"basis": "腰腹更紧凑,降纹改善但臂同质化抵消材质潜在收益;只给造型+1,不因修订次数加分。"
}
},
{
"candidateId": "C_P02",
"version": "v1",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"firstImpression": {
"identity": "蓝色U回环共鸣身的小人,顶黄色五浅瓣厚号口,红褐折叶臂、奶白鞋。",
"expression": "坚定眉、偏笑与前摆臂/迈步有运动感,神态偏自信朝观众,不是具体探索对象。"
},
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "U回管留大负形、叶芽状吹口和深厚外张号腔,让人用弯号读法直接成立。",
"flower": "五浅瓣的黄色口沿和植物状吹口让同一号口也读花冠;不是靠另贴自然花。",
"sharedGeometry": "U形管既为回号共鸣体也像回卷植物茎,上接同一花号口。",
"status": "同形双义成立",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 26,
"expressionCharm": 16,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 13,
"smallSizeMotion": 12
},
"scoreEvidence": {
"shapeCoordination": "紧凑U体与大口有明确整体轮廓,粗短腿稳定;花口仍偏重。",
"expressionCharm": "眉口与迈步同为坚定尝试,但目光面向观众,行为目标泛。",
"visibleCombination": "同形双义清楚,回管负形和深喉共同支持;花读法主要靠浅瓣/植物芽而非真实薄花。",
"materialColor": "蓝黄橙奶白职责清楚,折叶臂与胶鞋有厚薄差;部分指端仍软掌化。",
"smallSizeMotion": "96pxU回管、深号口、迈步与脸清楚;48px仍有回管负形、花号浅瓣及脸的点线,比长颈稿更保留结构,细眼神仍弱。 无动作补件与引擎验证。"
},
"total": 86,
"totalStatus": "暂定",
"coreReturn": {
"required": false,
"reason": "两种读法共享形体,非自然花插身体或另拿乐器。"
},
"issues": [
{
"type": "神态关系待加强",
"location": "瞳眼、眉和前手",
"evidence": "坚定偏笑读成自信卡通姿态,缺少明确在发现/尝试什么的共同注意。",
"target": "仅选择眼神与前手的一处目标,或用更具体微动作,让坚定尝试可见;保留U回管。",
"verification": "同条件新旧图并排,看共享轮廓/神态是否实际改善。"
},
{
"type": "执行偏差",
"location": "折叶前臂到指掌",
"evidence": "折叶边缘有薄面,掌指末端却变成厚圆橙手套,叶片材料转译在腕掌中断。",
"target": "让主折线和薄边进入掌指,保人形掌与拇指,不加密叶脉。",
"verification": "同条件新旧图并排,看共享轮廓/神态是否实际改善。"
}
],
"verification": {
"actualImageViewed": true,
"small96": "已实际打开绑定本版源图的真实高度96px",
"small48": "已实际打开绑定本版源图的真实高度48px",
"motion": "只观察主图姿势,动作补件与引擎未验",
"smallSizeFiles": [
"[本地来源路径]",
"[本地来源路径]"
],
"smallSizeObservation": "96pxU回管、深号口、迈步与脸清楚;48px仍有回管负形、花号浅瓣及脸的点线,比长颈稿更保留结构,细眼神仍弱。"
},
"status": "revise",
"scoreHistory": [
{
"stage": "主图首读",
"total": 85,
"smallSizeMotion": 11
},
{
"stage": "96/48px补证",
"total": 86,
"smallSizeMotion": 12,
"reason": "96pxU回管、深号口、迈步与脸清楚;48px仍有回管负形、花号浅瓣及脸的点线,比长颈稿更保留结构,细眼神仍弱。 尺寸动作11→12,其他分不变。"
}
]
},
{
"candidateId": "C_P02",
"version": "v2",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"firstImpression": {
"identity": "同一蓝U回号,橙臂连掌成为薄折叶,前掌向下伸向抬脚前方。",
"expression": "脸与前臂改为左下试探,偏笑仍坚定,比v1朝观众的通用自信姿态更具体。"
},
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "U回管留大负形、叶芽状吹口和深厚外张号腔,让人用弯号读法直接成立。",
"flower": "五浅瓣的黄色口沿和植物状吹口让同一号口也读花冠;不是靠另贴自然花。",
"sharedGeometry": "U形管既为回号共鸣体也像回卷植物茎,上接同一花号口。",
"status": "同形双义成立",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 26,
"expressionCharm": 17,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 14,
"smallSizeMotion": 12
},
"scoreEvidence": {
"shapeCoordination": "U回管、深口与迈步体量保持,前臂向下更利于具体行为。",
"expressionCharm": "脸偏左下、掌向地面,形成试下一步的共同方向;点眼仍无法强证精确指尖落点。",
"visibleCombination": "U回管与共享瓣状深口保持双读,未加道具或独立植物花。",
"materialColor": "橙臂折线/薄侧边贯穿掌指,软叶/实体身/胶鞋的差别更清楚,材质+1。",
"smallSizeMotion": "实看本版96/48:U负形、深口、下伸叶掌轮廓保留较好,点眼/细指关系仍弱;补证11→12,无运动验证。"
},
"total": 88,
"totalStatus": "暂定",
"coreReturn": {
"required": false,
"reason": "两种读法共享形体,非自然花插身体或另拿乐器。"
},
"issues": [
{
"type": "材料执行偏差",
"location": "黄号口实体卷边",
"evidence": "深喉与瓣形共同成立,但黄唇仍厚鼓似软胶/充气花,和轻薄成型号口的研究对照有距离。",
"target": "可试只压薄黄色卷边、保留深杯与五浅瓣,同一轮不再改脸臂。",
"verification": "同条件前后图对照;补新版真实96/48px,不套首版。"
},
{
"type": "缩图后仍有限的神态/掌指",
"location": "48px前手和点眼",
"evidence": "前伸掌的方向尚在,细掌折线和具体眼神难辨;结构优于长颈稿不等于用户已识别行为。",
"target": "停止本轮扩图,后续按实际显示尺度和用户观察核对,不为强调注意强加白大眼。",
"verification": "后续若继续,按同一版本与实际补证核对;本轮不再新增生成。"
}
],
"verification": {
"actualImageViewed": true,
"small96": "已实际看D本版96px,并用R独立裁片复核",
"small48": "已实际看D本版48px,并用R独立裁片复核",
"motion": "仅主图小步与前伸姿态,无动作/引擎验证",
"smallSizeFiles": [
"[本地来源路径]",
"[本地来源路径]"
]
},
"status": "revise",
"scoreHistory": [
{
"stage": "v2主图初评",
"total": 87,
"smallSizeMotion": 11
},
{
"stage": "v2缩图补证",
"total": 88,
"smallSizeMotion": 12,
"reason": "实看D v2缩图与R独立检查:U负形、深号口及下伸叶掌轮廓可保留,较静态判断补证+1;细指/点眼注意仍弱。"
}
],
"changes": {
"fromVersion": "v1",
"fromTotal": 86,
"toTotal": 88,
"delta": 2,
"scoreDeltas": {
"shapeCoordination": 0,
"expressionCharm": 1,
"visibleCombination": 0,
"materialColor": 1,
"smallSizeMotion": 0
},
"basis": "新图行为更具体、叶掌材料连贯各+1;新版未实测,不转用首版实测12,暂按静态11。整体+1。 后续实看新版缩图后尺寸动作恢复12,总分88;首评87留scoreHistory。"
}
},
{
"candidateId": "C_P02",
"version": "v3",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"firstImpression": {
"identity": "同一蓝U花号,黄口沿由厚鼓面改为细成形卷唇,深杯与五浅瓣仍在。",
"expression": "v2左下试探面向、前伸薄叶掌、偏笑与小步保留,未重画成新角色。"
},
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "深外张号腔、轻薄卷唇和连续U回管更像成形器物,叶芽吹口维持。",
"flower": "同一个卷唇自身五浅瓣起伏,花冠外边与号口边完全共享;没有新增花板或纸花。",
"sharedGeometry": "U回管/卷茎与薄壳号口/花冠均连续共形,主图未另持乐器。",
"status": "同形双义成立,薄口沿较v2更协调",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 27,
"expressionCharm": 17,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 14,
"smallSizeMotion": 12
},
"scoreEvidence": {
"shapeCoordination": "薄黄唇减少上部充气块感,深杯与管体仍连贯,形体组织较v2+1。",
"expressionCharm": "脸偏左下、掌向地面,形成试下一步的共同方向;点眼仍无法强证精确指尖落点。",
"visibleCombination": "共享深口/五浅瓣/回管完整保留,不因口沿变薄抹掉号身份;核心仍19,不为凑90加满。",
"materialColor": "薄壳号缘、折叶臂、密实胶鞋的厚薄职责更一致;体表轻微颗粒仍在,材料维持14。",
"smallSizeMotion": "R实际裁片96/48:U孔、花号浅瓣与深杯仍保留,v2/v3未见明显新增损失;仍有细眼神弱点,维持12。"
},
"total": 89,
"totalStatus": "暂定",
"coreReturn": {
"required": false,
"reason": "两种读法共享形体,非自然花插身体或另拿乐器。"
},
"issues": [
{
"type": "尚未验证的产品表现",
"location": "点眼注视、细叶掌与动态重心",
"evidence": "大图试探可读,48px具体注视与指掌折线弱;没有连续运动/岛上镜头证据。",
"target": "本轮停图;后续进入实际显示尺度/动作验证,不能写成引擎已通过。",
"verification": "后续若继续,按同一版本与实际补证核对;本轮不再新增生成。"
},
{
"type": "剩余表现问题",
"location": "蓝身/米鞋的细颗粒与整体风格",
"evidence": "共享结构已改善,但仍有细密材质颗粒和柔玩偶渲染,未证明符合用户最终审美。",
"target": "当前保留供用户比较;若后续继续仅做明确材质或表现测试,不为90盲改轮廓。",
"verification": "后续若继续,按同一版本与实际补证核对;本轮不再新增生成。"
}
],
"verification": {
"actualImageViewed": true,
"small96": "已实看R独立裁片96px,原图全身和裁框核对",
"small48": "已实看R独立裁片48px,未放大冒称通过",
"smallSizeFiles": [
"[本地来源路径]",
"[本地来源路径]"
],
"cropRecord": "[本地来源路径]",
"motion": "只看主图小步与前伸,未绑定/引擎/连续重心验证"
},
"status": "revise",
"scoreHistory": [
{
"stage": "v3主图与96/48首评",
"total": 89
}
],
"changes": {
"fromVersion": "v2",
"fromTotal": 88,
"toTotal": 89,
"delta": 1,
"scoreDeltas": {
"shapeCoordination": 1,
"expressionCharm": 0,
"visibleCombination": 0,
"materialColor": 0,
"smallSizeMotion": 0
},
"basis": "实际卷唇明显减薄,深喉/五浅瓣共边和v2身份保持;真实96/48未见新增结构丢失,造型+1,其余维持。不宣称精确减薄50%或零漂移。"
}
}
],
"pending": [
{
"candidateId": "A_P01",
"version": "v2",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "可见轻薄成形的外张深喉、细卷唇和连续粗弯管,号口身份增强。",
"flower": "同一片外张薄壳的五浅瓣外缘兼花冠,不是额外贴花。",
"sharedGeometry": "薄壳边界自身兼号唇和花缘,弯管兼承花茎,连续到梨形共鸣身。",
"status": "同形双义成立,口沿整合较v1改善",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 26,
"expressionCharm": 18,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 12,
"smallSizeMotion": 11
},
"total": 86,
"issues": [],
"status": "本轮已实审完成;未验证边界见该版本verification"
},
{
"candidateId": "A_P02",
"version": "v1",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "厚回管形成大环,沿上端延至深锥喉,有人用卷号的读法,不只是植物茎。",
"flower": "紫色口唇自身五浅瓣起伏,米白喉连续收拢;比外贴一圈平花瓣更融合。",
"sharedGeometry": "环体兼盘卷茎与号管,外张口唇兼瓣缘,路径连续,无独立头或手持号。",
"status": "同形双义成立",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 25,
"expressionCharm": 16,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 13,
"smallSizeMotion": 11
},
"total": 84,
"issues": [],
"status": "本轮已实审完成;未验证边界见该版本verification"
},
{
"candidateId": "B_P01",
"version": "v2",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "连续深喉、细卷唇和粗弯管读号;不是完整圆环再贴花板。",
"flower": "号唇自身五浅瓣,杏紫渐变沿同一壳面展开成花冠。",
"sharedGeometry": "同一外张面兼号口与花冠,弯管/号身兼植物路径;夹颚仍像下叉。",
"status": "同形双义成立,口沿两圈问题已改善",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 25,
"expressionCharm": 16,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 12,
"smallSizeMotion": 9
},
"total": 81,
"issues": [],
"status": "本轮已实审完成;未验证边界见该版本verification"
},
{
"candidateId": "B_P02",
"version": "v1",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "粗管回弯通向外张深号喉,能有号角读法;但横腹带孔更先像提壶/浇水壶,号身身份偏弱。",
"flower": "紫色花形外缘与米白号喉共用同一开口,但完整圆口加平瓣边层叠感明显。",
"sharedGeometry": "同一回管/茎通向花号,未另拿道具;然而壶状腹与双圈口让共形巧思被拆件感削弱。",
"status": "双读基本成立,乐器读法及口沿整合偏弱",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 23,
"expressionCharm": 15,
"visibleCombination": 16,
"materialColor": 12,
"smallSizeMotion": 10
},
"total": 76,
"issues": [],
"status": "本轮已实审完成;未验证边界见该版本verification"
},
{
"candidateId": "C_P01",
"version": "v2",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "深杯状号腔、厚口沿、通长S曲管与下部共鸣腹连通,右下小开口补号身读法。",
"flower": "珊瑚瓣缘与同一外张杯口共形,S曲管也像生长花茎,末端带叶芽。",
"sharedGeometry": "一条连续S路径兼号管/植物茎,花冠与号口完全共喉,不是另拿号。",
"status": "同形双义成立",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 26,
"expressionCharm": 17,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 13,
"smallSizeMotion": 11
},
"total": 86,
"issues": [],
"status": "本轮已实审完成;未验证边界见该版本verification"
},
{
"candidateId": "C_P02",
"version": "v3",
"subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
"doubleReading": {
"instrument": "深外张号腔、轻薄卷唇和连续U回管更像成形器物,叶芽吹口维持。",
"flower": "同一个卷唇自身五浅瓣起伏,花冠外边与号口边完全共享;没有新增花板或纸花。",
"sharedGeometry": "U回管/卷茎与薄壳号口/花冠均连续共形,主图未另持乐器。",
"status": "同形双义成立,薄口沿较v2更协调",
"gatePassed": true
},
"score": {
"shapeCoordination": 27,
"expressionCharm": 17,
"visibleCombination": 19,
"materialColor": 14,
"smallSizeMotion": 12
},
"total": 89,
"issues": [],
"status": "本轮已实审完成;未验证边界见该版本verification"
}
],
"selection": [
{
"candidateId": "C_P02",
"version": "v3",
"total": 89,
"reason": "共享回号最直接;薄壳卷唇改善且96/48结构保留,择优于v2。"
},
{
"candidateId": "C_P01",
"version": "v2",
"total": 86,
"reason": "侧听角色感最佳;S曲有辨识,厚瓣口和材料同质化仍待后续。"
}
],
"status": "completed_current_review_round_no_new_generation_pending",
"provisionalShortlist": [],
"note": "六概念十一张主图实际审完;C_P02 v2/v3已实看96/48,选v3,不再扩图。总分因无动作/引擎/用户识别验证仍标暂定,不等于生产验收。旧自然稿不适用。",
"alternate": {
"candidateId": "A_P01",
"version": "v2",
"total": 86,
"reason": "薄壳口沿整合好,幼态模板神态仍待用户判断;缩图未获显著神态增益。"
},
"researchViewed": [
"研究/P_双关纠偏/01_双关形体结论_设计直接使用.md",
"研究/P_双关纠偏/images/共享形体实图对照.jpg",
"研究/P_双关纠偏/images/rim_fold.jpg"
]
}