{ "schemaVersion": "1.2", "updated": "2026-11-08", "rubric": { "shapeCoordination": 30, "expressionCharm": 20, "visibleCombination": 20, "materialColor": 15, "smallSizeMotion": 15 }, "reviews": [ { "candidateId": "A01", "version": "v1", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "一只戴紫花、灰绿手套和紫靴的赭黄色块茎小人;上部大花首先抓眼。", "expression": "仰头张口、抬右手,像在招呼或看手上方;天真感可见,注意目标略泛。", "relationship": "花经弯茎接身体,手套袖臂与胶靴有分部;不是金色乐器。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 24, "expressionCharm": 16, "visibleCombination": 16, "materialColor": 11, "smallSizeMotion": 9 }, "total": 76, "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "三案差异待同路三图到齐;当前未见直接复制参考部件的画面证据,未作原创性外部核验。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "生成执行偏差", "location": "整身表皮、两臂与花面", "evidence": "躯干覆盖密集裂片,手套有颗粒织纹,花口细脉连续铺满;像写实材质玩偶,细节抢过角色大形。", "target": "优先减少微纹理,以少量宽明暗保留干燥身体、软布臂、胶鞋的差异;不靠全局磨成同一种塑料。", "verification": "同屏比较面部/花/材料是否先于纹理被看到。" }, { "type": "生成执行偏差", "location": "头顶萼座至花喉之间", "evidence": "茎向上伸出一段明显细长弧线,花与脸之间空隙大;原方案短萼托的紧凑关系未实现。", "target": "缩短裸露茎、降低花与身体的分离感,保留弯曲方向和显眼花,不同步扩大花。", "verification": "前后并排检查花脸是否读成一组,脸不被挤小。" }, { "type": "概念结构待验证", "location": "双臂肘腕、身体底部与鞋口", "evidence": "袖口与肘部都有环形折叠,短腿完全隐于身体;站立清楚,但屈肘与提膝路径看不出。", "target": "下轮保留手套身份,明确一处肘弯和腕连接;用一张屈臂/迈步补件检查,不以加长所有肢体解决。", "verification": "主图加动作结构图;观察上臂/前臂分段和鞋口抬起时与躯干的空间。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "待验", "small48": "待验", "motion": "仅静态结构推断,未有动作补件", "engine": "未验;不作为首批硬退回条件", "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证" }, "status": "revise", "notes": "主图分,不采用文字自评90。小尺寸与动作项为静态概念判断分,未表示实测通过。", "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "不对称块茎和双靴稳定,长裸茎拉松花脸关系。", "expressionCharm": "上看眼、张口和抬手同向,注意目标仍泛。", "visibleCombination": "花/块茎/手套直接可见,关节与短腿结构信息不足。", "materialColor": "赭身、灰绿臂、紫花紫鞋有呼应;密纹令写实质感过重。", "smallSizeMotion": "手掌和鞋轮廓清楚,肘腕环折与隐腿妨碍结构判断;未缩小实测。" }, "totalStatus": "暂定", "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "A02", "version": "v1", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "大杏白花长在细高的开荚豆人上,麻绳臂、紫鞋,明显在迈步。", "expression": "挑眉和偏笑较自信,双眼朝右前,动作轻快;与抬手的共同注意对象不够明确。", "relationship": "豆荚包住浅色种仁脸,侧绕藤和麻绳臂清楚;内部穿藤只能推断。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 24, "expressionCharm": 16, "visibleCombination": 18, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 10 }, "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "荚的长曲线与绳臂有节奏,但上花很大、下身极窄。", "expressionCharm": "挑眉偏笑不依赖娃娃脸,视线与张开的手未组成明确事件。", "visibleCombination": "荚壳/种仁脸、绕藤开花、绳臂直接可见,三物关系有依据。", "materialColor": "杏花、灰绿荚、棕臂和紫鞋分工明确,宽明暗比A01简洁。", "smallSizeMotion": "迈步鞋底可见,细荚和短脸缩小时有风险;未作96/48px实测。" }, "total": 81, "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "未作外部原创性核验;不把无引擎动画列为首批硬退回。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "生成执行偏差", "location": "大花、花颈与小脸", "evidence": "花冠横向远宽于荚身,脸压在中下部窄腔内;一眼先看到花,再找人物。", "target": "缩短花颈或试收花口横宽,二者只先改一项;保留瘦长荚身身份,提升脸的可见份量。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "概念关系待加强", "location": "双眼、抬手与前摆腿", "evidence": "微笑与迈步可读,抬手像礼貌招呼,未显示特定好奇或探索对象。", "target": "让眼睛与前手形成更明确共同注意点,或把手改为试探触碰微姿态,不增加道具。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "结构待验证", "location": "荚壳底部分叉与鞋口", "evidence": "壳片同时充当腿,抬脚时两片如何分离不够清楚;主图只有单一步态。", "target": "补屈膝/侧步的壳腿连接图,检查是否需要短腿根或局部折转;不把内穿藤路径当已验证。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "待验", "small48": "待验", "motion": "按主图静态结构观察,未验证动作序列", "engine": "未验", "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证" }, "status": "revise", "notes": "小尺寸动作项为静态概念判断分,不代表实测通过。", "totalStatus": "暂定", "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "A03", "version": "v1", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "浅紫大漏斗花本身就是脸,陶土萼片收成身体,枝臂和绿靴。", "expression": "两小眼和O形嘴在花喉内显出惊讶,但大花面包着小五官,角色表情份量偏小。", "relationship": "花脸—萼身—枝臂关系一眼可见,区别于花顶在无脸身体上的方案。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 25, "expressionCharm": 15, "visibleCombination": 18, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 10 }, "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "花喉下收至萼身形成连续大曲线,枝臂尺度协调;花冠视觉重量过大。", "expressionCharm": "小圆口与上看眼可读,但更像统一惊讶符号,手和脸联系弱。", "visibleCombination": "三种自然原型的转译直接,不靠说明补关系。", "materialColor": "蓝紫花/土橙萼/暖棕枝/灰绿鞋柔和,材质靠形态与厚薄成立。", "smallSizeMotion": "实看v1 96/48px:脸的嘴与注视点严重弱化,48px近乎无表情;较首评11降为10。" }, "total": 81, "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "未作外部原创性核验;不把无引擎动画列为首批硬退回。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "概念比例待调整", "location": "花喉内的五官与外花冠", "evidence": "花冠占据很大上部面积,五官集中在偏小的喉心;表情被大花装饰性包住。", "target": "先试让五官更靠近前花喉、提高表情份量;不直接新增独立娃娃头,也不必扩大整朵花。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "概念神态待加强", "location": "双眼、小圆口与抬起枝掌", "evidence": "小O嘴和双椭圆眼给出惊讶,但枝掌只是扬起,没有明确探索行为。", "target": "在惊讶基础上增加一次有目标的轻触/观察手势,眼神跟随同一位置;保留花脸身份。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "结构待验证", "location": "下收萼瓣、腿分叉与鞋口", "evidence": "萼片收成两条下垂尖端插鞋,站立成立;抬腿时会不会像整片花萼折断未明。", "target": "补一张小步与屈腿结构,确定自然折转或短连接部位,不需引擎动画。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "已实际查看D/check01中绑定v1源图的96px图;见observations", "small48": "已实际查看D/check01中绑定v1源图的48px图;见observations", "motion": "按主图静态结构观察,未验证动作序列", "engine": "未验", "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证", "observations": "96px花/身体/手脚可认,脸很小,嘴和视线很难辨;48px五官近乎消失,只有花人剪影。", "smallSizeFiles": [ "[本地来源路径]", "[本地来源路径]" ], "silhouette": "已实看48px派生剪影,主体差异可辨;未审全分辨率遮罩精度,非生产透明资产验收。" }, "status": "revise", "notes": "小尺寸动作项为静态概念判断分,不代表实测通过。", "totalStatus": "暂定", "scoreHistory": [ { "stage": "首评", "total": 82, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 25, "expressionCharm": 15, "visibleCombination": 18, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 11 } }, { "stage": "v1缩图补证", "total": 81, "reason": "96px花/身体/手脚可认,脸很小,嘴和视线很难辨;48px五官近乎消失,只有花人剪影。小尺寸动作11→10;其余分项不变。" } ], "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "A03", "version": "v2", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "花喉五官明显变大、向前唇靠近,枝掌弯回花缘,仍是花本体有脸。", "expression": "双眼、张口和近花缘指尖形成共同事件,比v1泛泛惊讶更完整。", "relationship": "花脸—萼身—枝臂关系保留,无新增娃娃头。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 26, "expressionCharm": 17, "visibleCombination": 18, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 11 }, "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "五官前移使花脸紧凑,大花体量仍重。", "expressionCharm": "枝掌回弯和前移双眼建立观察花缘的神态,瞳孔仍略朝前。", "visibleCombination": "花本体承载脸,萼身枝臂胶鞋清楚。", "materialColor": "紫花、橙萼、木枝、绿鞋保留,未借重配色掩饰结构。", "smallSizeMotion": "实际补图有短连接段与抬鞋,无清楚膝弯;v2缩图待验。" }, "total": 85, "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "未作外部原创性核验;不把无引擎动画列为首批硬退回。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "神态精修待比较", "location": "双眼与花唇旁枝指", "evidence": "枝指接近花唇使事件成立,但大椭圆瞳孔仍偏朝前,凝视小间隙不够明确。", "target": "仅微调共同瞳孔目标或枝指位置之一,勿继续放大五官变娃娃脸。", "verification": "下版主图/补件同条件对照,按实际图核对。" }, { "type": "小尺寸待验", "location": "五官与花冠", "evidence": "主图表情份量提高,不能据此认定48px可读;v1实缩图已出现五官消失。", "target": "补绑定v2源图的96/48px检查,先评估简化眼口,不扩大整花。", "verification": "下版主图/补件同条件对照,按实际图核对。" }, { "type": "动作执行偏差/结构待验", "location": "动作补图短连接段与鞋口", "evidence": "两根短连接段与倾斜抬鞋可见,无清楚膝弯;更像改变踝部,未验证计划的屈腿。", "target": "保留补件为候选解释,明确腿在哪里弯或界定只能小步的概念范围。", "verification": "下版主图/补件同条件对照,按实际图核对。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "v2待验,不套v1", "small48": "v2待验,不套v1", "motion": "已实看A03_v2_motion.png:短连接段/抬鞋可见,膝弯未验证", "engine": "未验", "supplements": [ "[本地来源路径]" ], "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证" }, "status": "revise", "notes": "小尺寸动作项为静态概念判断分,不代表实测通过。", "totalStatus": "暂定", "changes": { "fromVersion": "v1", "fromTotal": 82, "toTotal": 85, "delta": 3, "scoreDeltas": { "shapeCoordination": 1, "expressionCharm": 2, "visibleCombination": 0, "materialColor": 0, "smallSizeMotion": 0 }, "basis": "新主图五官前移放大与枝掌回弯改善造型/神态;动作补图只增加连接解释,不加动作分。" }, "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "B01", "version": "v1", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "紫色兔耳状扁夹体托着白花,绳臂绿腿紫鞋,像穿围裙的小园丁。", "expression": "一高一低眉与小开嘴有亲和,也带犹豫担心,天真探索意图不够肯定。", "relationship": "前后两片夹体与上U槽可见,但花茎在槽上方伸得很长,夹持关系弱于装饰性。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 23, "expressionCharm": 15, "visibleCombination": 17, "materialColor": 12, "smallSizeMotion": 11 }, "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "扁身、绳臂、短腿尺度统一,花颈过长,上下像两段物件。", "expressionCharm": "小开口和非对称眉有情绪,略担心而非清楚好奇。", "visibleCombination": "夹颚前后厚片可见,三段成立;第一眼夹具原型偏弱。", "materialColor": "紫身紫鞋呼应,但身体与鞋近似同一软哑表面,硬/软分别不足。", "smallSizeMotion": "手臂负形和迈步可读;花颈长、浅白花小尺寸对浅底不利,未实测。" }, "total": 78, "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "未作外部原创性核验;不把无引擎动画列为首批硬退回。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "生成执行偏差", "location": "U形夹口、裸露花茎和大叶", "evidence": "U槽上方有很长裸茎与大叶,花头离身体远;夹口像背心肩带而非承托节点。", "target": "缩短裸露茎、收大叶面积,强化夹口与茎的贴合和保护,不添加机械弹簧来硬解释。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "生成执行偏差", "location": "紫色夹体厚边与鞋面", "evidence": "前后厚片有轮廓,但其表面柔软感接近紫胶鞋,硬夹与软鞋差异不足。", "target": "让夹体用清楚厚边/少量较利转折显硬,鞋保圆软;不靠换三种强色区分。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "神态选择待调整", "location": "双眉、眼睛与伸掌", "evidence": "一眉担心式下弯,配微张嘴,容易读成拿不准或求助。", "target": "保留谨慎个性但给出清楚好奇注意点,先只调整眉形或眼神之一,不重画整脸。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "待验", "small48": "待验", "motion": "按主图静态结构观察,未验证动作序列", "engine": "未验", "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证" }, "status": "revise", "notes": "小尺寸动作项为静态概念判断分,不代表实测通过。", "totalStatus": "暂定", "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "B02", "version": "D-v2", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "活叶脸与分陶壳植物小人,花口比v1稍收窄。", "expression": "看掌眼神、偏笑与迈步保留。", "relationship": "陶壳围抱、绳穿陶孔、活茎叶脸均维持。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 27, "expressionCharm": 17, "visibleCombination": 18, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 11 }, "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "花口稍收令叶脸相对份量改善,改变量温和。", "expressionCharm": "瞳孔共同看掌、轻笑和迈步连贯,较有角色感。", "visibleCombination": "活植物穿陶壳及绳孔关系可见;内侧腹茎连接仍被壳遮挡。", "materialColor": "紫花/绿叶/橙陶/米绳/青鞋面积层级成立,大色块较清楚;各材质仍偏玩具哑面。", "smallSizeMotion": "薄绳与小掌、叶面五官缩小风险明显;盆壳与迈步腿的间隙仅可推断,未实测。" }, "total": 86, "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "未作外部原创性核验;不把无引擎动画列为首批硬退回。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "比例对照结论", "location": "花口与叶脸", "evidence": "花口稍收后脸相对份量改善,仍先看到花;没有解决全部角色份量问题。", "target": "可优先保留D-v2作对照,与短颈D-v3实际比较再定,不无限缩花。", "verification": "下版主图/补件同条件对照,按实际图核对。" }, { "type": "结构待验证", "location": "陶壳中央缝、腹茎与双腿根", "evidence": "中央绿茎和两腿可见,但分陶壳迈步时如何固定、与腿的活动范围没有直接证据。", "target": "补侧面或较大步幅的静态连接图,明确壳托住何处;不增加复杂背带或零碎机关。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "小尺寸风险待验", "location": "细绳手臂、托掌与叶脸瞳孔", "evidence": "发现感依赖小掌和眼球方向,细绳在缩小时可能断读;当前全尺寸不能证明能保住神态。", "target": "由D先做96/48px实看,若丢失则只加粗绳掌或简化瞳孔,保留当前视线逻辑。", "verification": "96/48px按角色实际高度显示,分别记录能否看见脸、掌、手臂。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "D-v2待验", "small48": "D-v2待验", "motion": "仅主图结构观察,B路补件待验", "engine": "未验", "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证" }, "status": "revise", "notes": "小尺寸动作项为静态概念判断分,不代表实测通过。", "totalStatus": "暂定", "changes": { "fromVersion": "v1", "fromTotal": 85, "toTotal": 86, "delta": 1, "scoreDeltas": { "shapeCoordination": 1, "expressionCharm": 0, "visibleCombination": 0, "materialColor": 0, "smallSizeMotion": 0 }, "basis": "实际花口收窄改善叶脸相对份量。未测准确缩窄百分比,不把实验目标12%当实测。" }, "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "B02", "version": "D-v3", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "同一叶脸、陶壳与绳臂植物人,花略降低,与v1视觉差异小于收花口的D-v2。", "expression": "看掌偏笑保留,神态未出现新的提升。", "relationship": "组合关系保持;花宽仍压过叶脸,颈短变化温和。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 26, "expressionCharm": 17, "visibleCombination": 18, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 11 }, "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "花稍低但横宽保留,角色份量改善弱于D-v2,维持v1造型26。", "expressionCharm": "瞳孔共同看掌、轻笑和迈步连贯,较有角色感。", "visibleCombination": "活植物穿陶壳及绳孔关系可见;内侧腹茎连接仍被壳遮挡。", "materialColor": "紫花/绿叶/橙陶/米绳/青鞋面积层级成立,大色块较清楚;各材质仍偏玩具哑面。", "smallSizeMotion": "薄绳与小掌、叶面五官缩小风险明显;盆壳与迈步腿的间隙仅可推断,未实测。" }, "total": 85, "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "未作外部原创性核验;不把无引擎动画列为首批硬退回。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "比例对照结论", "location": "花颈与花口", "evidence": "花略向下,横宽与v1几乎相同;大花仍为第一注意点,未形成明显优于v1的整体关系。", "target": "不自动选最新D-v3;与D-v2并排后优先保留更清楚的花口收窄方案。", "verification": "同高度比较,实际改变量不能直接等同提示词百分比。" }, { "type": "结构待验证", "location": "陶壳中央缝、腹茎与双腿根", "evidence": "中央绿茎和两腿可见,但分陶壳迈步时如何固定、与腿的活动范围没有直接证据。", "target": "补侧面或较大步幅的静态连接图,明确壳托住何处;不增加复杂背带或零碎机关。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "小尺寸风险待验", "location": "细绳手臂、托掌与叶脸瞳孔", "evidence": "发现感依赖小掌和眼球方向,细绳在缩小时可能断读;当前全尺寸不能证明能保住神态。", "target": "由D先做96/48px实看,若丢失则只加粗绳掌或简化瞳孔,保留当前视线逻辑。", "verification": "96/48px按角色实际高度显示,分别记录能否看见脸、掌、手臂。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "D-v3待验", "small48": "D-v3待验", "motion": "仅主图结构观察,不能套原版新增陶托已冻结", "engine": "未验", "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证" }, "status": "revise", "notes": "小尺寸动作项为静态概念判断分,不代表实测通过。", "totalStatus": "暂定", "changes": { "fromVersion": "v1", "fromTotal": 85, "toTotal": 85, "delta": 0, "basis": "D-v3独立来自v1,不累加D-v2。实看仍保大花宽,降低幅度温和,未有足以提高分项的新收益。" }, "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "B02", "version": "v1", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "活的心形叶脸站在打开的陶盆壳中,头上大紫花,绳臂托掌,绿腿青鞋。", "expression": "双眼看向伸出的掌,小偏笑和迈步一起形成安静发现感,注意对象较明确。", "relationship": "陶盆保护身体、绳穿陶孔、植物由中间长出,关系直接而有理由,区别于普通盆上贴脸。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 26, "expressionCharm": 17, "visibleCombination": 18, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 11 }, "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "叶脸、分陶壳与短腿形成清楚层级,宽体与大花互相平衡;花仍稍抢脸。", "expressionCharm": "瞳孔共同看掌、轻笑和迈步连贯,较有角色感。", "visibleCombination": "活植物穿陶壳及绳孔关系可见;内侧腹茎连接仍被壳遮挡。", "materialColor": "紫花/绿叶/橙陶/米绳/青鞋面积层级成立,大色块较清楚;各材质仍偏玩具哑面。", "smallSizeMotion": "薄绳与小掌、叶面五官缩小风险明显;盆壳与迈步腿的间隙仅可推断,未实测。 已实看v1 96/48px确认小脸/手掌信息损失,保留原分,不宣称通过。" }, "total": 85, "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "未作外部原创性核验;不把无引擎动画列为首批硬退回。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "概念比例待比较", "location": "紫花与心叶脸的上下体量", "evidence": "大花在上部先抓眼,叶脸虽清楚,仍成为花与盆之间的一层。", "target": "做一个只略收花口横宽或降低花颈的受控对照,优先保住活叶脸身份与手掌注意关系,不另增头。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "结构解释新增/未冻结", "location": "补图球腹、底托与陶壳连接", "evidence": "补图让根冠坐在可见底托上,两腿分开可跨步;球腹与底托是新增的结构解释,视角仍偏正,背部马蹄连接未展示充分。", "target": "决定保留后同步主图和真正侧/背面;补图保留为探索,不写成原版已藏有并验证该结构。", "verification": "正侧背同一根冠/陶托结构,明确下肢让位。" }, { "type": "小尺寸风险待验", "location": "细绳手臂、托掌与叶脸瞳孔", "evidence": "发现感依赖小掌和眼球方向,细绳在缩小时可能断读;当前全尺寸不能证明能保住神态。", "target": "由D先做96/48px实看,若丢失则只加粗绳掌或简化瞳孔,保留当前视线逻辑。", "verification": "96/48px按角色实际高度显示,分别记录能否看见脸、掌、手臂。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "已实际查看D/check01中绑定v1源图的96px图;见observations", "small48": "已实际查看D/check01中绑定v1源图的48px图;见observations", "motion": "已实看B02_v1_结构补件.png:更长跨步与独立腿根可见,但新增球腹和底部陶托,角度仍偏正,属于结构解释候选;未验证原主图隐藏背侧连接。", "engine": "未验", "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证", "observations": "96px叶脸和眼白可读;48px花叶盆层级仍在,但瞳孔方向与小掌的发现关系丢失,绳臂接近细线。", "smallSizeFiles": [ "[本地来源路径]", "[本地来源路径]" ], "silhouette": "已实看48px派生剪影,主体差异可辨;未审全分辨率遮罩精度,非生产透明资产验收。", "supplements": [ "[本地来源路径]" ] }, "status": "revise", "notes": "小尺寸动作项为静态概念判断分,不代表实测通过。", "totalStatus": "暂定", "scoreHistory": [ { "stage": "首评", "total": 85, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 26, "expressionCharm": 17, "visibleCombination": 18, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 11 } }, { "stage": "v1缩图补证", "total": 85, "reason": "96px叶脸和眼白可读;48px花叶盆层级仍在,但瞳孔方向与小掌的发现关系丢失,绳臂接近细线。原首评已保留此项风险,本次确认风险,分数不变。" } ], "evidenceUpdates": [ { "type": "补件", "scoreChanged": false, "basis": "新增球腹/陶托尚未在主图冻结;仅提供可行画法,不自动增加原图动作分。" } ], "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "B03", "version": "v1", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "一只白灰卷口种植袋小人,顶侧向紫钟花,绿手套、棕绳腿和橙靴。", "expression": "压低眉、偏笑、前伸平掌与跨步形成自信尝试,略显得意而非天真好奇。", "relationship": "柔袋折面、卷口生花、织臂胶掌、绳腿胶鞋都直接可见,三段来源比较清楚。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 25, "expressionCharm": 16, "visibleCombination": 18, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 11 }, "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "偏心软袋与大折面有设计,前后步态成立;花钟转侧与前手方向不一致。", "expressionCharm": "眼眉和偏嘴有角色性,自信清楚;瞳孔方向不明显,探索对象泛。", "visibleCombination": "袋/花/园艺手套的功能联系直接,但束口画成宽敞卷口。", "materialColor": "袋浅灰、紫花、绿臂与橙鞋分工清楚,材料用折面/针织/胶掌区分;仍有织纹。", "smallSizeMotion": "宽袋和手掌轮廓可辨,绳腿和鞋有间隙;96/48px和屈腿未验。" }, "total": 83, "totalStatus": "暂定", "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "未作外部原创性核验;动作/小尺寸待验不构成硬退回。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "生成执行偏差", "location": "卷口与花茎接点", "evidence": "袋口大开,像卷边花盆;没有形成说明中的收束包护关系。", "target": "适度收拢袋口并保留软折面,让花茎被包护,勿改成硬陶盆。", "verification": "下版同条件比较,不以说明补画面。" }, { "type": "概念神态/方向待调整", "location": "眼睛、前伸掌与侧向花口", "evidence": "身体向左前尝试,花朝侧后上,眼睛近似朝前;注意关系分散。", "target": "先让眼神与前掌形成共同目标,保留自信;再决定是否转花,不同时大改三处。", "verification": "下版同条件比较,不以说明补画面。" }, { "type": "生成执行偏差", "location": "织臂细条与掌腕厚度", "evidence": "臂上连续针织沟纹较密,掌端偏厚胶手套,平薄织带概念被削弱。", "target": "简化织纹、让腕掌厚度过渡更清楚,保留胶掌与袋体差异。", "verification": "下版同条件比较,不以说明补画面。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "待验", "small48": "待验", "motion": "仅主图静态结构观察,未验证动作序列", "engine": "未验", "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证" }, "status": "revise", "changes": null, "notes": "当前总分暂定,实际补证状态见verification。", "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "C01", "version": "v1", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "一只长紫色牵牛花、扭绳手臂与紫色鞋的宽土豆小人。", "expression": "眼睛向抬手处看,小张嘴、眉毛上提,配合试探迈步,惊奇与探索感比A01更完整。", "relationship": "植物从上后侧生出,块茎身体、柔性臂与胶鞋区分清楚;手臂第一眼更像编绳而非卷须。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 24, "expressionCharm": 17, "visibleCombination": 17, "materialColor": 12, "smallSizeMotion": 10 }, "total": 80, "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "三案差异待同路三图到齐;未作原创性外部核验。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "生成执行偏差", "location": "花面、块茎皮与扭臂", "evidence": "花瓣密脉、土豆细绒皮和臂的纤维条纹仍很具象;颜色层级清楚但整体更像精细3D玩偶。", "target": "先降低连续微纹,保留不规则块茎外轮廓、少数生长眼及花口宽明暗。", "verification": "与原图并排,首先读到表情和结构而非皮肤。" }, { "type": "概念转译/执行偏差混合", "location": "左右前臂至手掌", "evidence": "整段上肢由等粗的两股螺旋构成,尤其垂臂第一眼是麻花绳;现实卷须的轻细、生长式弯曲没有形成自己的特征。", "target": "减少全长等距缠绕,选保留一处绕合或生长接点,让腕和手掌过渡更自然;保留柔性植物臂与块茎的差别。", "verification": "遮住说明再看,判断是植物生长臂还是普通编绳臂;并检查抬手轮廓。" }, { "type": "概念结构待验证", "location": "宽躯干底缘、两侧腿根和鞋口", "evidence": "迈步鞋底可见,动作意图成立;但宽厚身体下只有极短腿根,提膝与较大屈髋可能受体块遮挡。", "target": "用一张稍大幅屈腿/抬膝结构补件检验;必要时调整底缘腿窝与鞋口留隙,保留宽块茎身份。", "verification": "动作补件中可区分左右鞋、腿根及身体的遮挡层次,不将二维图称为引擎动作验证。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "待验", "small48": "待验", "motion": "主图有试探迈步;仅结构观察,未验证动作序列", "engine": "未验;不作为首批硬退回条件", "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证" }, "status": "revise", "notes": "当前两稿中C01神态更完整,但尚不能据两稿认定全轮最佳;不采用文字自评92。", "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "宽块茎与上侧花有重心对照,长绞臂略机械。", "expressionCharm": "瞳孔、眉、张口、抬手和试步共同表达惊奇。", "visibleCombination": "三段材质可见,卷须转译更像编绳。", "materialColor": "紫花紫鞋呼应,皮/臂/胶差别明确,表面纹理偏密。", "smallSizeMotion": "迈步鞋底和腿根可见,宽身遮挡大幅提膝的可能路径;未缩小实测。" }, "totalStatus": "暂定", "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "C01", "version": "v2", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "灰米色宽团块顶粉花,浅绿扭臂和深苔鞋;比v1更简洁,但第一眼土豆身份减弱。", "expression": "仰看抬手、张嘴和试步保留,惊奇探索仍可读。", "relationship": "短花颈把花脸拉近;身/臂/鞋分部仍清楚,但身体更像柔软石团,绳臂仍等距缠绕。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 25, "expressionCharm": 17, "visibleCombination": 16, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 10 }, "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "花颈明显缩短,花脸更紧凑;不规则宽体保留,略显无骨软团。", "expressionCharm": "双眼、张口和抬手的共同注意仍成立,未因简化丢失原神态。", "visibleCombination": "少数浅凹可见,块茎皮身份弱于v1;上肢仍像编绳,原型关系少一层直接性。", "materialColor": "大色块与宽明暗取代密脉/细绒,粉灰绿深苔有层级;全身柔哑表面仍趋同。", "smallSizeMotion": "迈步可见,但短腿根仍被宽身遮挡,未补较大动作和缩图。" }, "total": 81, "totalStatus": "暂定", "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "未作外部原创性核验;动作/小尺寸待验不构成硬退回。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "概念转译/执行偏差混合", "location": "宽身体轮廓与两处浅凹", "evidence": "降纹后偏柔软团块,灰米皮肤与宽阴影更像软石或面团;土豆原型识别下降。", "target": "通过少量不规则硬软转折、凹点边缘和底缘收束恢复干燥块茎身份;不恢复满身颗粒。", "verification": "下版同条件比较,不以说明补画面。" }, { "type": "未解决的概念转译问题", "location": "两段长扭臂", "evidence": "仍是两股等粗、近等距麻花,浅绿换色并未增加植物生长臂特征。", "target": "减少全长等距缠绕,只保留一处绕合/生长接点,完善腕掌过渡。", "verification": "下版同条件比较,不以说明补画面。" }, { "type": "结构待验证", "location": "身体底缘与鞋口腿根", "evidence": "缩短花颈未改变短腿根遮挡,大幅提膝仍无证据。", "target": "用较大幅屈膝补件验证,必要时调整底缘腿窝,不据现有迈步图认定运动通过。", "verification": "下版同条件比较,不以说明补画面。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "待验", "small48": "待验", "motion": "仅主图静态结构观察,未验证动作序列", "engine": "未验", "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证" }, "status": "revise", "changes": { "fromVersion": "v1", "fromTotal": 80, "toTotal": 81, "delta": 1, "scoreDeltas": { "shapeCoordination": 1, "expressionCharm": 0, "visibleCombination": -1, "materialColor": 1, "smallSizeMotion": 0 }, "basis": "实际新图:短花颈改善花脸联系;密纹减少令2.5D信息密度改善;但块茎身份退弱,绞绳臂未解决。不是由补文案变分。" }, "notes": "当前总分暂定,实际补证状态见verification。", "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "C02", "version": "v1", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "一只绿色双鼓包豆荚,顶珊瑚钟花,金黄折叶袖与紫色细腿,正在高抬膝。", "expression": "眉眼偏坚定自信,抬掌像邀约或展示,探索感比C01弱。", "relationship": "花、豆荚、折叶臂可读,手掌却更像软手套而非干叶延展。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 25, "expressionCharm": 16, "visibleCombination": 17, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 11 }, "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "纵向双鼓包和侧缝建立身份,斜上花口与抬腿有动势。", "expressionCharm": "眉眼坚决、偏笑与提膝一致,但和张掌的动作目的偏泛。", "visibleCombination": "花/荚/叶臂成立,折叶到手掌的材质转接弱。", "materialColor": "珊瑚花、灰绿荚、麦黄叶臂、石板紫腿鞋层级明确,微纹少。", "smallSizeMotion": "提膝结构和鞋底可见,细腿与尖荚尾在缩图可能粘连;未实测。 已实看v1 96/48px确认小脸/手掌信息损失,保留原分,不宣称通过。" }, "total": 82, "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "未作外部原创性核验;不把无引擎动画列为首批硬退回。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "生成执行偏差", "location": "折叶袖、腕和手掌", "evidence": "叶臂有清楚折面和中脉,末端变为饱满圆手掌;植物纸叶身份在腕部中断。", "target": "保留掌形和拇指,但让腕掌厚度与折面衔接,避免变成叶袖包普通手套。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "概念表现待加强", "location": "眉眼、嘴和抬掌", "evidence": "眉微内收、嘴偏笑有坚定感;右掌朝上更像介绍或表演,与运动尝试关系松。", "target": "保持坚定气质,选前伸试探或前摆臂其一,令眼神与动作有具体共同目标。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "结构待验证", "location": "荚尖、髋部、抬起膝盖", "evidence": "膝盖可见但腿从侧缘后方伸出;长尖荚尾靠近支撑腿,侧向动作的碰撞未明。", "target": "交一张较小幅提膝及一张侧面连接补件,先确认腿根与尖尾让位再精修。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "已实际查看D/check01中绑定v1源图的96px图;见observations", "small48": "已实际查看D/check01中绑定v1源图的48px图;见observations", "motion": "按主图静态结构观察,未验证动作序列", "engine": "未验", "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证", "observations": "96px提膝与大形可见,脸和叶掌信息压缩;48px脸变小点,叶臂材质不可辨,提膝剪影仍有区别。", "smallSizeFiles": [ "[本地来源路径]", "[本地来源路径]" ], "silhouette": "已实看48px派生剪影,主体差异可辨;未审全分辨率遮罩精度,非生产透明资产验收。" }, "status": "revise", "notes": "小尺寸动作项为静态概念判断分,不代表实测通过。", "totalStatus": "暂定", "scoreHistory": [ { "stage": "首评", "total": 82, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 25, "expressionCharm": 16, "visibleCombination": 17, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 11 } }, { "stage": "v1缩图补证", "total": 82, "reason": "96px提膝与大形可见,脸和叶掌信息压缩;48px脸变小点,叶臂材质不可辨,提膝剪影仍有区别。原首评已保留此项风险,本次确认风险,分数不变。" } ], "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "C02", "version": "v2", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "细长双鼓豆荚顶珊瑚花,折叶臂前伸,较小幅试步。", "expression": "朝右前的眉眼与前伸掌比介绍式抬掌更像坚定试探;双臂仍偏平展。", "relationship": "叶折面伸到掌背;侧图新增髋部圈形接头,尚不与主图完全一致。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 26, "expressionCharm": 17, "visibleCombination": 18, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 12 }, "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "降低提膝与延伸叶臂改善动势,尖荚和两腿有间隙。", "expressionCharm": "前伸掌与朝右前的脸共同试探,仍有平衡步读法。", "visibleCombination": "叶折面接近掌背,手臂更像同一叶;指端仍厚圆。", "materialColor": "原四组材色保留,改进来自结构,叶指仍像软手套。", "smallSizeMotion": "正侧图可见弯腿与尖荚让位,静态结构补证+1;侧图接圈未冻结,v2缩图待验。" }, "total": 86, "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "未作外部原创性核验;不把无引擎动画列为首批硬退回。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "未完全解决的执行偏差", "location": "掌指端和拇指", "evidence": "折面接到手背,指端仍是厚圆软掌,叶的厚薄未贯穿。", "target": "只压薄掌指边缘或保留一两处折角,勿增加密叶脉。", "verification": "下版主图/补件同条件对照,按实际图核对。" }, { "type": "神态待比较", "location": "眼睛与平展双臂", "evidence": "试探比v1明确,双臂平展仍像平衡或展示,缺少强指尖注视点。", "target": "只调整前臂角度或共同注视点之一,保留坚定,不再改腿幅。", "verification": "下版主图/补件同条件对照,按实际图核对。" }, { "type": "补件漂移/结构未冻结", "location": "侧图髋部圈形接头", "evidence": "侧图新增灰色圈形接头,主图未明确同一结构;只能证明一种可画的让位方案。", "target": "接圈记候选解释,决定保留后同步主图;较大屈髋另验。", "verification": "下版主图/补件同条件对照,按实际图核对。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "v2待验", "small48": "v2待验", "motion": "已实看C02_v2_side.png:荚尖让位与膝弯可见;新增接圈未冻结", "engine": "未验", "supplements": [ "[本地来源路径]" ], "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证" }, "status": "revise", "notes": "小尺寸动作项为静态概念判断分,不代表实测通过。", "totalStatus": "暂定", "changes": { "fromVersion": "v1", "fromTotal": 82, "toTotal": 86, "delta": 4, "scoreDeltas": { "shapeCoordination": 1, "expressionCharm": 1, "visibleCombination": 1, "materialColor": 0, "smallSizeMotion": 1 }, "basis": "新图叶臂接掌、前伸动作、低提膝分别改善;实际侧图补静态动作证据1。未验证v2缩图或引擎。" }, "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" }, { "candidateId": "C03", "version": "v1", "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]", "firstImpression": { "identity": "顶圆绿叶的陶橙倒锥小人,粗浅绿臂、奶油鞋,身体更像带孔陶块而非直接读成莲蓬。", "expression": "斜眼和弯嘴显得放松,手托向一旁;空心式深色扁眼看不出看向哪只手,好奇不强。", "relationship": "圆叶经长柄接倒锥体,手脚俱全;叶与身体像伞和托座,莲蓬来源较弱。" }, "score": { "shapeCoordination": 25, "expressionCharm": 14, "visibleCombination": 16, "materialColor": 13, "smallSizeMotion": 11 }, "scoreEvidence": { "shapeCoordination": "宽肩下收与弯腿平衡,圆叶偏左和躯干偏右有呼应;长柄使两块体量分离。", "expressionCharm": "扁深眼和微笑偏安逸,缺少明确注意点;双手姿态仍有亲和。", "visibleCombination": "无花植物对照在授权内;倒锥莲蓬的三孔更像人工陶孔,植物原型转译弱。", "materialColor": "橙身、绿臂叶、奶油鞋有层级;手臂光滑管状,纤维材质较弱。", "smallSizeMotion": "大鞋/粗臂和扁身轮廓清楚,脸和圆叶在小尺寸能否保留神态待验。" }, "total": 79, "hardReturn": { "required": false, "reasons": [], "pending": "未作外部原创性核验;不把无引擎动画列为首批硬退回。" }, "issues": [ { "type": "概念神态待调整", "location": "扁斜眼、弯嘴和伸掌", "evidence": "两眼是深色扁椭圆,视线方向不显;嘴和手势读成轻松介绍,未呈现看掌的探索意图。", "target": "先让两眼有共同注意目标或改眼轴,再保留偏嘴和当前手势对照,不强制大白眼。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "概念转译/执行偏差混合", "location": "倒锥体上缘三孔与皮面", "evidence": "三孔大而深、边缘规整,橙体像陶制孔块;原说明要求浅凹点和有机莲蓬形。", "target": "收浅孔洞、让上缘有少量有机厚薄差,保留干燥材质,避免增加密孔密纹。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" }, { "type": "生成执行偏差", "location": "叶柄、叶与肩部", "evidence": "长裸叶柄把大圆叶撑离脸,读作举伞;上部面积大而信息集中在很小脸区。", "target": "优先缩短叶柄或改变贴肩弯曲其一,令圆叶像角色生长结构,保留非花对照身份。", "verification": "下版同条件并排检查对应部位,动作项需补结构图。" } ], "verification": { "actualImageViewed": true, "small96": "待验", "small48": "待验", "motion": "按主图静态结构观察,未验证动作序列", "engine": "未验", "smallSizeMotionStatus": "小尺寸/静态补件分别见本版本记录;无引擎验证" }, "status": "revise", "notes": "小尺寸动作项为静态概念判断分,不代表实测通过。", "totalStatus": "暂定", "stage": "历史旧阶段", "currentDirectionStatus": "本轮核心未成立" } ], "selection": [], "status": "historical_current_direction_core_not_established", "comparison": "B02 v1=85、D-v2=86、D-v3=85。D-v2收益最清楚;D-v3不因更新获选。C01v2=81,比v1+1。A03v1因缩图补证82→81;A03v2主图改善暂定85;C02v2主图和侧图补证暂定86。未将任何稿定为用户正式IP。", "measurement": { "method": "读取原PNG,对蓝紫花体用b>r*1.08且b>g*1.10且r>100的统一色阈值做粗包围盒,只作色区范围佐证,非精确轮廓/颈长测量", "sourceSizes": [ 1230, 1278 ], "flowerColorBBoxes": { "v1": [ 180, 21, 857, 442 ], "D-v2": [ 228, 21, 796, 438 ], "D-v3": [ 181, 28, 858, 454 ] }, "conclusion": "D-v2花色色区横宽568px,v1 677px;D-v3同为677px而范围稍下移。阈值不能验证颈长减少18%或设计百分比。" }, "stage": "历史:自然植物混搭阶段;已被08_双关纠偏与本轮任务覆盖", "currentDirectionQualification": "同形双义未成立;旧分仅保留过程,不可作为本轮符合方向依据。", "historicalSelection": [ { "candidateId": "B02", "version": "D-v2", "total": 86, "status": "本轮推荐,仍待用户选择", "reason": "叶脸看掌与陶壳围抱关系直接;花口略收改善脸的相对份量。遗留细绳小掌缩图、壳托结构未冻结。" }, { "candidateId": "C02", "version": "v2", "total": 86, "status": "本轮推荐,仍待用户选择", "reason": "细长双鼓荚和折叶试探动作兼容性更强,侧图增加静态让位证据。遗留厚圆叶指、侧图接圈漂移和新版缩图待验。" } ], "historicalAlternate": { "candidateId": "A03", "version": "v2", "total": 85, "reason": "花脸组合差异强,前移五官改善神态;v2小尺寸待验,动作补图膝弯不成立,暂列后备。" }, "correction": { "basis": "[本地来源路径]", "error": "此前评审错误排除喇叭结构,把自然植物组合误作为核心。", "withdrawn": "此前B02-D-v2/C02-v2推荐仅为旧误读方向内部比较,撤回其当前方向适用性。", "currentGate": "同一形体同时读出人使用的喇叭与花。自然花加身体、花角色另拿喇叭不合格。" } }