← 喇叭花改版

评审来源

来源标题与会议时点保留;本机文件链接改为文字。原话与整理说明按原文件分别标注。

下载文字

{
  "stage": "D-077任天堂风格开放探索",
  "date": "2026-11-09",
  "rubric": {
    "punFusion": 25,
    "overallCharacter": 30,
    "materialTruth": 20,
    "expressionIntent": 20,
    "deliveryClarity": 5
  },
  "reviews": [
    {
      "candidateId": "N_A01",
      "version": "v1",
      "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
      "firstImpression": "带大橙色花头的陶盆探险小人,侧挂黄铜回管与按键,手拿放大镜,挎工具包,穿登山鞋。",
      "expression": "大白眼朝放大镜/上方,O嘴、抬手与跨步形成鲜明惊讶和探索感;意图依赖手持道具。",
      "coreGate": {
        "status": "本轮核心未成立,退回",
        "eligible": false,
        "instrumentReading": "主要来自头左侧独立黄铜回管和两枚号键;能认乐器零件,但其管路如何进入上方同一花口不可见。",
        "flowerReading": "上部为有条脉、花蕊/花药、软起伏缘的橙色自然花,深处可见花蕊填充,第一读为百合式花冠。",
        "sharedShapeEvidence": "有外张花腔这种一般形状相似,但缺少同一号口边界/号喉与侧管连通的明确证据。不能用相邻金管+天然花两个对象的存在替代同形双义。",
        "bodyConnection": "萼叶托花头并接陶盆身体,独立躯干本身不构成缺陷;不要求改成全管身。",
        "consequence": "其他材质与神态分不能抵消核心缺失,当前不进入两案优选。"
      },
      "score": {
        "punFusion": 10,
        "overallCharacter": 23,
        "materialTruth": 16,
        "expressionIntent": 17,
        "deliveryClarity": 4
      },
      "total": 70,
      "totalStatus": "诊断参考分;核心未成立,不合格进入优选",
      "scoreEvidence": {
        "punFusion": "自然花与侧面号管是相邻部件,主口未直接兼号口;陶盆/萼座有生长承托逻辑,但号键/配件不能补核心。",
        "overallCharacter": "大花头、陶盆短身、厚鞋形成完整好认人物,跨步有活力;黄铜圈、包、工具、放大镜与多处叶纹共同争注意,融合像装备叠加多于共享形体。",
        "materialTruth": "陶盆硬粗边、针织可弯臂腿、白织手套、皮鞋软亮和黄铜反光有真实区别;上肢与腿同为针织,鞋的皮革独立,接合仍偏服装穿戴。真实材质不是扣分原因。",
        "expressionIntent": "瞳孔、O嘴、举镜和跨步共同表达惊奇检查,情绪鲜明;人格依靠放大镜而非本体姿态,当前17。",
        "deliveryClarity": "中性浅底,完整花和双鞋、脸可见;装备遮住盆身部分主要结构,略影响直接读体块。"
      },
      "promptAudit": {
        "actualPromptRead": true,
        "anqi4732": "实际prompt完整含安琦47:32原文,已核",
        "openBaseline": "没有预锁躯干/材质/配色/眼公式,符合N_A01开放基线;生成后模型选择陶盆/针织/皮鞋,不因开放方法加减图分。",
        "modelAdditions": [
          "放大镜",
          "挎包与肩带",
          "铲子/卷图",
          "侧面号键"
        ],
        "differenceFromInstruction": "prompt明确要求同一口花号;实际画面转为自然花+侧挂金管。新增道具不在必要规格内。"
      },
      "issues": [
        {
          "type": "生成执行偏差/核心结构退回",
          "location": "头顶花口—左侧金属回管",
          "evidence": "花口内三枚花药和自然花壁占主要读法,侧面黄铜管/号键另担乐器身份,主口未读共享号喉。",
          "target": "保独立陶盆和大花的开放探索成果,让同一开口有可见外张号喉与植物瓣缘,侧管若保留须直接连入该口;减少掩喉花蕊/独立号键,不用整身号管替代身体。",
          "verification": "先遮说明和侧键,主开口仍能同时读人用号口与花冠;侧管路径可直接追踪。"
        },
        {
          "type": "生成新增道具/整体层级",
          "location": "放大镜、挎包工具与胸前肩带",
          "evidence": "这些新增物件帮助解释探险,却遮身体并增加小识别中心,核心融合被装备替代。",
          "target": "去放大镜与工具包/肩带/工具,保一处抬掌或触碰的惊奇动作及当前活泼体态;材料真实度可保,不按2.5D抹纹理。",
          "verification": "无道具时仍能从眼口与动作看出具体好奇;盆身/花口接合和手脚材料更直接。"
        }
      ],
      "verification": {
        "actualImageViewed": true,
        "smallSize": "本轮未测,不冒称通过",
        "motion": "仅主图跨步,未绑定/引擎验证"
      },
      "status": "core_return"
    },
    {
      "candidateId": "N_A02",
      "version": "v1",
      "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
      "firstImpression": "两片不对称软木裂壳夹住绿铜三浅瓣花号,毡叶臂卷折,草编鞋。",
      "expression": "半眯眼、侧笑与伸掌像机敏/狡黠自信,具体好奇目标不强。",
      "coreGate": {
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "共享双关成立,第三夹合可见",
        "instrumentReading": "氧化铜成形深号喉、金属卷唇及圆截面弯管,有完整器物结构与材质证据。",
        "flowerReading": "同一铜号唇外张成三浅瓣,不是圆口外贴自然花;管下叶片与弯茎相连。",
        "sharedShapeEvidence": "花缘/号唇同一边界,曲管/茎同体;两壳上口卷扣把号根夹住,第三原型参与承托。"
      },
      "score": {
        "punFusion": 23,
        "overallCharacter": 25,
        "materialTruth": 18,
        "expressionIntent": 16,
        "deliveryClarity": 5
      },
      "scoreEvidence": {
        "punFusion": "铜花号和壳夹根实际共用结构,非配件堆叠。",
        "overallCharacter": "两壳偏斜与扁卷臂节奏独特;头顶较重,脸小且眼神未指明确目标。",
        "materialTruth": "软木剥片、毡毛与编草的触感/厚薄差清楚;真实纹理允许,但大块剥片稍抢脸。",
        "expressionIntent": "半眯侧笑有区别,当前更狡黠而非明确发现;视线不落伸掌。",
        "deliveryClarity": "全身清楚、无场景遮挡,夹合与鞋均可见。"
      },
      "total": 87,
      "totalStatus": "当前概念参考分;不替代用户选择",
      "issues": [
        {
          "type": "神态/意图",
          "location": "半眯眼、侧笑与前手",
          "evidence": "眼睛半眯不等高,嘴偏笑,伸掌指向却未形成共同关注,偏狡黠。",
          "target": "只调整眼神/眉口与前掌共同目标,保留机敏小眼,不换成大白眼开心脸。",
          "verification": "新旧版本同条件实看,不靠说明补结构。"
        },
        {
          "type": "生成执行偏差",
          "location": "毡叶腕掌",
          "evidence": "袖臂薄卷像叶,末端变粗厚圆指,叶毡的片状语言到手中断。",
          "target": "让扁掌侧边和主折延续到手指,保毡毛材质,不全身磨平。",
          "verification": "新旧版本同条件实看,不靠说明补结构。"
        }
      ],
      "verification": {
        "actualImageViewed": true,
        "smallSize": "未测",
        "motion": "仅主图姿态,未绑定/引擎验证"
      },
      "status": "revise"
    },
    {
      "candidateId": "N_A02",
      "version": "v2",
      "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
      "firstImpression": "同一裂壳铜花号,双掌从厚圆毡指变为薄叶片,嘴小开、眉较舒展。",
      "expression": "较v1少狡黠,像注意前手弯折;暗色小眼没有充分瞳孔方向,精确看指尖仍只能弱判断。",
      "coreGate": {
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "共享双关成立,第三夹合可见",
        "instrumentReading": "氧化铜成形深号喉、金属卷唇及圆截面弯管,有完整器物结构与材质证据。",
        "flowerReading": "同一铜号唇外张成三浅瓣,不是圆口外贴自然花;管下叶片与弯茎相连。",
        "sharedShapeEvidence": "花缘/号唇同一边界,曲管/茎同体;两壳上口卷扣把号根夹住,第三原型参与承托。"
      },
      "score": {
        "punFusion": 23,
        "overallCharacter": 25,
        "materialTruth": 19,
        "expressionIntent": 17,
        "deliveryClarity": 5
      },
      "scoreEvidence": {
        "punFusion": "铜质深喉、成形卷唇/三浅瓣与曲管/茎保留;裂壳夹合未漂移,核心仍23。",
        "overallCharacter": "主要比例、构造与站姿基本不变,脸部更轻;造型维持25,不重复给材质改进加分。",
        "materialTruth": "掌指显薄侧边和片状折面,毡袖到掌的构造连续,较v1材料+1;软木/草编仍有区别。",
        "expressionIntent": "眉舒展、小开嘴减轻自满感,与微内弯前掌更协调,+1;半眯上睑仍有,不能声称精准注视完全解决。",
        "deliveryClarity": "全身/夹根/花口完整,无新增道具。"
      },
      "total": 89,
      "totalStatus": "当前概念参考分;不替代用户选择",
      "issues": [
        {
          "type": "神态尚未完全实现",
          "location": "小眼轴与内弯指尖",
          "evidence": "小嘴和眉松开有效,仍有半眯眼,暗眼难确认双眼是否落同一指尖空隙。",
          "target": "保本版供用户看机敏/好奇的区别;若后续做神态,只针对注视而不加大白眼。",
          "verification": "后续若继续,应绑定同版实测;本轮结束不再扩图。"
        },
        {
          "type": "尚未验证的动作/尺寸",
          "location": "毡薄掌、草鞋和木根腿",
          "evidence": "大图掌形更好,但薄掌在实际缩小后、硬根腿在运动中如何表现没有证据。",
          "target": "后续按真实尺度/动作核验;不据静态步姿声称绑定通过。",
          "verification": "后续若继续,应绑定同版实测;本轮结束不再扩图。"
        }
      ],
      "verification": {
        "actualImageViewed": true,
        "comparedDirectlyTo": "[本地来源路径]",
        "smallSize": "未测",
        "motion": "仅主图姿态,未引擎/绑定"
      },
      "status": "review_complete",
      "changes": {
        "fromVersion": "v1",
        "fromTotal": 87,
        "toTotal": 89,
        "delta": 2,
        "scoreDeltas": {
          "punFusion": 0,
          "overallCharacter": 0,
          "materialTruth": 1,
          "expressionIntent": 1,
          "deliveryClarity": 0
        },
        "basis": "实际薄掌/折面改善材质,眉口减狡黠提高神态;结构比例未改,不为新版自动涨造型分。"
      }
    },
    {
      "candidateId": "N_B01",
      "version": "v1",
      "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
      "firstImpression": "斜木肩榫托住灰青珊瑚边花号,绿薄叶臂、帆布鞋。",
      "expression": "挑眉偏笑配前伸叶掌,机灵友好;更像介绍而非明确试探。",
      "coreGate": {
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "共享双关基本成立,木肩接合成立",
        "instrumentReading": "灰青成形圆管、显厚薄的卷唇与连续深锥喉像非金属号筒;不是仅一个柔软自然花口。",
        "flowerReading": "同一外张口的四浅波参与真实口沿,暖色内面与叶臂形成植物读法。",
        "sharedShapeEvidence": "粗曲号颈/茎一体,斜木槽两颊托夹根部;身份不依赖独立道具。"
      },
      "score": {
        "punFusion": 22,
        "overallCharacter": 26,
        "materialTruth": 18,
        "expressionIntent": 17,
        "deliveryClarity": 5
      },
      "scoreEvidence": {
        "punFusion": "同口及斜榫夹根可见;园艺打孔器具体身份未由图证明,只能判木握部/木托。",
        "overallCharacter": "宽木身、纤叶臂和小步体块清楚;整体略像通用木偶,独特性不如裂壳。",
        "materialTruth": "木、蜡叶和帆布清楚,叶掌厚薄贯穿;真实纹理不扣风格分。",
        "expressionIntent": "挑眉/笑口同意图,眼神仍泛向前手上方,17。",
        "deliveryClarity": "脸、主接合、全鞋均无遮挡。"
      },
      "total": 88,
      "totalStatus": "当前概念参考分;不替代用户选择",
      "issues": [
        {
          "type": "神态/行为",
          "location": "眼神与前伸掌",
          "evidence": "前掌像介绍,眼睛未形成可见共同探查点。",
          "target": "只改视线与微掌势为明确探索,保小眼与叶臂身份。",
          "verification": "新旧版本同条件实看,不靠说明补结构。"
        },
        {
          "type": "新增融合可见性",
          "location": "肩部木槽",
          "evidence": "能读托夹却无法读出园艺握柄/打孔器关系,第三原型仍泛木块。",
          "target": "若推进,强化单一木肩套接用途,或如实把原型降为木制握部,不加工具道具。",
          "verification": "新旧版本同条件实看,不靠说明补结构。"
        }
      ],
      "verification": {
        "actualImageViewed": true,
        "smallSize": "未测",
        "motion": "仅主图姿态,未绑定/引擎验证"
      },
      "status": "revise"
    },
    {
      "candidateId": "N_B02",
      "version": "v1",
      "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
      "firstImpression": "绿色双鼓豆荚人,顶红橙花口,拉菲绳臂、栗壳鞋,前伸试步。",
      "expression": "斜眉小笑和前手有坚定尝试感,注意点还偏泛。",
      "coreGate": {
        "eligible": false,
        "status": "喇叭第二读法未充分可辨,需结构重审",
        "instrumentReading": "有深腔和粗曲颈/卷环,但整体高亮绿色自然管壁、花脉与红花缘更像自然花;缺少更明确器物口/管的形体组织。",
        "flowerReading": "蜡质荚与自然花的连续植物读法很强。",
        "sharedShapeEvidence": "荚缝到颈下卷环即中断,像插上自然花;不能因有腔和环就判同形双义充分。",
        "consequence": "暂不入优选,先补第二读与连续卷荚逻辑。"
      },
      "score": {
        "punFusion": 15,
        "overallCharacter": 24,
        "materialTruth": 17,
        "expressionIntent": 17,
        "deliveryClarity": 5
      },
      "scoreEvidence": {
        "punFusion": "第二读弱,原计划荚壁卷管被环套插接打断。",
        "overallCharacter": "圆荚与前探姿态连贯,但粗绳指像结团抢手部意图。",
        "materialTruth": "荚/干纤维/栗壳鞋分部真实,绳臂刚柔被过粗体量掩盖。",
        "expressionIntent": "坚定表情与试步一致,比纯招手明确;具体注视弱。",
        "deliveryClarity": "无道具,双鞋完整,接环清楚可见。"
      },
      "total": 78,
      "totalStatus": "当前概念参考分;不替代用户选择",
      "issues": [
        {
          "type": "核心融合执行偏差",
          "location": "号喉/曲管与荚缝卷环",
          "evidence": "植物漏斗先行;荚缝停在一圈套环,未实现同片荚壁卷出器物感号管。",
          "target": "重建可追踪的荚壁卷管/茎与成形号喉,减少插接环;增强器物结构,不靠增加阀键。",
          "verification": "新旧版本同条件实看,不靠说明补结构。"
        },
        {
          "type": "手部执行偏差",
          "location": "绳掌与拇指",
          "evidence": "绳团厚而难读指掌的前探。",
          "target": "保干纤维,减绳团而明确掌/拇指,不换通用塑料手套。",
          "verification": "新旧版本同条件实看,不靠说明补结构。"
        }
      ],
      "verification": {
        "actualImageViewed": true,
        "smallSize": "未测",
        "motion": "仅主图姿态,未绑定/引擎验证"
      },
      "status": "core_return"
    },
    {
      "candidateId": "N_B02",
      "version": "v2",
      "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
      "firstImpression": "同一双鼓绿荚,套环消失,浅荚缘沿曲管背面延续,号腔光顺成形,绳掌变细扁。",
      "expression": "坚定脸/前伸姿势保留,掌指更清楚,注意对象仍泛。",
      "coreGate": {
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "共享双关基本成立,恢复候选资格;卷壁解释仍不充分",
        "instrumentReading": "光顺规则的外张号锥、薄成形卷唇与圆截面粗弯管现在共同提供器物读法,较v1自然花壁明显增强;深处收窄圆喉仍偏侧、不够清楚。",
        "flowerReading": "浅瓣同一个号唇与荚壁/浅荚缘共用,植物读法持续。",
        "sharedShapeEvidence": "完整独立套环已消除,腹缝浅缘从肩连至管背,曲管/茎同体;但指令中的卷壁C截面并未充分露出,不能称同片荚壁成管已完全证明。",
        "consequence": "本版可以进入比较,仍不及A02/C01的整体角色与核心证据。"
      },
      "score": {
        "punFusion": 21,
        "overallCharacter": 25,
        "materialTruth": 18,
        "expressionIntent": 17,
        "deliveryClarity": 5
      },
      "scoreEvidence": {
        "punFusion": "规则成型号腔/曲管和连续荚缘替代自然花+套环,器物第二读与新增融合都有画面改善,15→21;C截面及圆喉仍弱,未给满。",
        "overallCharacter": "去环后肩颈更连贯,扁绳掌少了结团,造型24→25;新颈偏长仍拉大上部。",
        "materialTruth": "干纤维掌指更扁、拇指清楚,编绳组织与蜡荚/硬栗壳分别更有依据,17→18。",
        "expressionIntent": "脸和前探动作基本保留,仍泛坚定17;不因手细就同时抬神态分。",
        "deliveryClarity": "全身及连续荚缘清楚,无新增道具。"
      },
      "total": 86,
      "totalStatus": "当前概念参考分;不替代用户选择",
      "issues": [
        {
          "type": "结构解释未完全落实",
          "location": "荚壁卷接边与圆喉",
          "evidence": "荚缘连续可见,C形卷壁切口未充分露出;收喉位在侧暗部,不能证明具体成管工艺。",
          "target": "本轮保留改善,后续若推进,用一个实际可见卷壁内外面验证,不加解释冒称工艺成立。",
          "verification": "后续若继续,应绑定同版实测;本轮结束不再扩图。"
        },
        {
          "type": "比例及动作未验",
          "location": "长曲颈与前探绳掌",
          "evidence": "新颈更长,号/脸间分离增加;扁掌改善但大动作柔性未验。",
          "target": "后续按用户选择验证,当前不为挤进前二追加生图或套用v1动作结论。",
          "verification": "后续若继续,应绑定同版实测;本轮结束不再扩图。"
        }
      ],
      "verification": {
        "actualImageViewed": true,
        "comparedDirectlyTo": "[本地来源路径]",
        "smallSize": "未测",
        "motion": "仅主图姿态,未引擎/绑定"
      },
      "status": "review_complete",
      "changes": {
        "fromVersion": "v1",
        "fromTotal": 78,
        "toTotal": 86,
        "delta": 8,
        "scoreDeltas": {
          "punFusion": 6,
          "overallCharacter": 1,
          "materialTruth": 1,
          "expressionIntent": 0,
          "deliveryClarity": 0
        },
        "basis": "实图去环、连续荚缘、规则号喉和细扁绳掌提供新证据,核心由退回变基本成立;未把未生成清楚的C截面或圆喉写通过。"
      }
    },
    {
      "candidateId": "N_C01",
      "version": "v1",
      "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
      "firstImpression": "矮宽葫芦/梨形干壳人,蓝布手套臂、木鞋,粗弯花号与一支小侧吹口。",
      "expression": "前倾体、低前伸掌、眼向掌、眉鼻与露齿偏笑共同显出好奇又有点淘气的试探。",
      "coreGate": {
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "共享双关成立,人物整合较强",
        "instrumentReading": "侧面小吹口与粗曲管、明显深号喉形成同体风管关系,不单靠自然漏斗;主口有成形卷唇。",
        "flowerReading": "橙色同口边四浅起伏与萼叶抓根,自然生长路径仍清楚。",
        "sharedShapeEvidence": "号口/花冠与弯管/花茎共形,萼片夹抓葫芦颈,独立干壳体不违反新范围。"
      },
      "score": {
        "punFusion": 22,
        "overallCharacter": 27,
        "materialTruth": 17,
        "expressionIntent": 18,
        "deliveryClarity": 5
      },
      "scoreEvidence": {
        "punFusion": "同口与同管有吹口关系支持;葫芦共鸣壳读法尚不及普通梨形果实直接。",
        "overallCharacter": "宽腹、布肘、大木鞋连成活泼低重心人物;花号偏大长,头上视觉重量过强。",
        "materialTruth": "布折和木硬边真实,三段区别清楚;橙色躯干的饱满皮面更像梨果,未充分表现干葫芦硬壳,故17。纹理多本身不扣分。",
        "expressionIntent": "眼、嘴、前掌与迈步共同试探,鼻/牙让个性鲜明,略有常见冒险角色模板感。",
        "deliveryClarity": "全身无道具,脸及接点可见。"
      },
      "total": 89,
      "totalStatus": "当前概念参考分;不替代用户选择",
      "issues": [
        {
          "type": "体量执行偏差",
          "location": "花号与弯颈相对腹脸",
          "evidence": "花口和弯颈明显大长,先看巨花再看角色;与低重心前探体有分离。",
          "target": "只试适度缩短裸弯颈/收花口其中一个,保同口深喉、侧吹口和当前神态,别改为全管身。",
          "verification": "新旧版本同条件实看,不靠说明补结构。"
        },
        {
          "type": "原型转译",
          "location": "干葫芦壳外面",
          "evidence": "当前橙色鼓面像梨果,干壳与共鸣容器身份未充分可见。",
          "target": "用少量宽干壳转折/生长硬边强化壳体而非加满纹理;保独立自然壳身体。",
          "verification": "新旧版本同条件实看,不靠说明补结构。"
        }
      ],
      "verification": {
        "actualImageViewed": true,
        "smallSize": "未测",
        "motion": "仅主图姿态,未绑定/引擎验证"
      },
      "status": "revise",
      "scoreHistory": [
        {
          "stage": "初评分项录入",
          "total": 90
        },
        {
          "stage": "干壳材料证据复核",
          "total": 89,
          "reason": "壳体的干燥/硬壳身份不充分,画面更像饱满梨果皮。不能把三段分色和织物/木鞋真实直接等同躯干原型真实,材料18→17。"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "candidateId": "N_C01",
      "version": "v2",
      "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
      "firstImpression": "同一宽葫芦前探人物,花号稍贴近身体,低腹和侧边增加宽浅硬壳面。",
      "expression": "前手、瞳孔、低身迈步和露齿偏笑保留,人物行为仍是最鲜明的好奇前探。",
      "coreGate": {
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "共享双关成立,人物整合较强",
        "instrumentReading": "侧面小吹口与粗曲管、明显深号喉形成同体风管关系,不单靠自然漏斗;主口有成形卷唇。",
        "flowerReading": "橙色同口边四浅起伏与萼叶抓根,自然生长路径仍清楚。",
        "sharedShapeEvidence": "号口/花冠与弯管/花茎共形,萼片夹抓葫芦颈,独立干壳体不违反新范围。"
      },
      "score": {
        "punFusion": 22,
        "overallCharacter": 27,
        "materialTruth": 18,
        "expressionIntent": 18,
        "deliveryClarity": 5
      },
      "scoreEvidence": {
        "punFusion": "侧吹口—粗曲管—共享深喉/瓣口仍可追踪,萼抓壳颈;没有另挂独立号,核心仍22。",
        "overallCharacter": "裸颈有所收短,花更靠身体,但同直径大花仍偏重;比例改善温和,造型仍27。",
        "materialTruth": "侧腹与低腹的宽转面/浅硬壳边确实出现,比v1饱满果皮更像干壳,材料17→18;脸仍清楚,未靠满身加纹。",
        "expressionIntent": "眼、嘴、前掌与迈步的同一行为保持,18;没有因改壳面再加神态分。",
        "deliveryClarity": "全花、脸、双鞋和萼抓根可见,局部未遮断。"
      },
      "total": 90,
      "totalStatus": "当前概念参考分;不替代用户选择",
      "issues": [
        {
          "type": "比例仍未完全解决",
          "location": "大花口相对腹脸",
          "evidence": "裸颈缩短使体块近一些,但大口本身保持原径,仍占大量上部注意;不是整体比例已完美。",
          "target": "本轮保留v2优于v1的紧凑与壳感,交用户并排比较,勿为更高分连续缩花。",
          "verification": "后续若继续,应绑定同版实测;本轮结束不再扩图。"
        },
        {
          "type": "原型/运动仍待验证",
          "location": "干葫芦壳与布肩/木腿",
          "evidence": "干壳感提高但仍可能被先读成梨果人,未有结构内侧或动作/岛镜头证据。",
          "target": "后续根据用户识别与真实表现决定壳感和接点,不把90当已定原型或生产验收。",
          "verification": "后续若继续,应绑定同版实测;本轮结束不再扩图。"
        }
      ],
      "verification": {
        "actualImageViewed": true,
        "comparedDirectlyTo": "[本地来源路径]",
        "smallSize": "未测",
        "motion": "仅主图姿态,未引擎/绑定"
      },
      "status": "review_complete",
      "changes": {
        "fromVersion": "v1",
        "fromTotal": 89,
        "toTotal": 90,
        "delta": 1,
        "scoreDeltas": {
          "punFusion": 0,
          "overallCharacter": 0,
          "materialTruth": 1,
          "expressionIntent": 0,
          "deliveryClarity": 0
        },
        "basis": "实际增加宽干壳转折,材料+1;花颈变紧凑但口仍大,造型不加;神态未变不加。90为分项和,不是必须到达的结果,也不宣称正式通过。"
      }
    },
    {
      "candidateId": "N_C02",
      "version": "v1",
      "subjectImage": "[本地来源路径]",
      "firstImpression": "打开的高V绿荚包种仁脸,紫大花、木枝关节臂和酒红皮鞋,抬手遮眉远望。",
      "expression": "遮眉手与上看眼、偏笑及长步形成远望探索,意图明确。",
      "coreGate": {
        "eligible": false,
        "status": "自然花读法主导,喇叭第二读未充分成立",
        "instrumentReading": "紫口有连续卷边/深漏斗,但颈呈植物纤维、主体像自然牵牛;当前器物身份主要靠文字,不能以空腔/卷边自动判号口。",
        "flowerReading": "紫自然花管、厚蜡荚和种仁完整植物读法强。",
        "sharedShapeEvidence": "荚口夹粗茎清楚,第三原型融合成立,但主口缺乏充分乐器读法证据。",
        "consequence": "保远望与荚夹结构作探索,但当前不入双关强稿优选。"
      },
      "score": {
        "punFusion": 14,
        "overallCharacter": 25,
        "materialTruth": 18,
        "expressionIntent": 18,
        "deliveryClarity": 5
      },
      "scoreEvidence": {
        "punFusion": "同口器物第二义弱;荚夹种仁/花管的融合可见,是有价值的身体探索。",
        "overallCharacter": "高V与长枝臂/交叉步有鲜明修长节奏,关节略机械拼接。",
        "materialTruth": "蜡荚、枝木与皮鞋区别真实,手/枝厚薄可见;躯干/腿同植材鞋仍独立。",
        "expressionIntent": "遮眉远望与双眼上看有明确共同目标,神态较好。",
        "deliveryClarity": "全身清楚无道具,跨步/枝腕运动未验证。"
      },
      "total": 80,
      "totalStatus": "当前概念参考分;不替代用户选择",
      "issues": [
        {
          "type": "核心第二读待重做",
          "location": "紫花口及曲颈",
          "evidence": "可读自然牵牛与卷边,但没有足够器物结构让人同时认号,不能借写名补足。",
          "target": "保荚夹种仁与远望,重做同一口的成形号喉/圆截面曲管,仍兼植物茎,别另外挂号。",
          "verification": "新旧版本同条件实看,不靠说明补结构。"
        },
        {
          "type": "执行偏差",
          "location": "枝肘和掌腕节点",
          "evidence": "整圈关节像装配式木偶,遮眉掌虽有效,生命感被关节拼装削弱。",
          "target": "只简化一两处枝节点并连续到掌,不必改皮鞋或整体修长体。",
          "verification": "新旧版本同条件实看,不靠说明补结构。"
        }
      ],
      "verification": {
        "actualImageViewed": true,
        "smallSize": "未测",
        "motion": "仅主图姿态,未绑定/引擎验证"
      },
      "status": "core_return"
    }
  ],
  "selection": [
    {
      "candidateId": "N_C01",
      "version": "v2",
      "total": 90,
      "reason": "本轮最完整的试探角色感;壳感与花颈实际改善,保留独立身及材料组织。"
    },
    {
      "candidateId": "N_A02",
      "version": "v2",
      "total": 89,
      "reason": "共享铜花号及裂壳夹根最有区别,毡掌/轻好奇改善。"
    }
  ],
  "status": "本轮九张实际审评完成,无待图,无追加生成",
  "diversity": {
    "observed": "陶盆探险装/裂壳夹合/硬木榫托/双鼓荚/宽葫芦/高V单仁荚均有身体构造差异;非仅换色。无整身号管稿,最多一案条件未超出。",
    "material": "布/毡/草编/叶/拉菲/干壳/木/皮/帆布有真实差别。",
    "limitations": "B02/C02同为荚,但一个连续双鼓偏斜、一个V夹种仁远望,仍属结构和行为差异。橙绿配色及珠眼仍有复用倾向,不能只用贴品牌名证明风格。"
  },
  "note": "全部评分为本轮概念比较;90不是强制门槛,不替代用户定稿、实际识别或动作验收。保留六v1与三v2;未做96/48和引擎,不写通过。",
  "promptAudit": {
    "A": "N_A01实际prompt完整含47:32原话,开放基线真实;已读。",
    "B": "N_B01实际prompt忠实译文,已读。",
    "C": "N_C01实际prompt中文关键原句,已读。",
    "scope": "A01方法合规不等于核心通过。新材质/3D光照不因取消2.5D被处罚。"
  },
  "alternate": {
    "candidateId": "N_B01",
    "version": "v1",
    "total": 88,
    "reason": "木肩榫托、叶臂和布鞋成熟,但选择A02提供更不同构造的可比较方向;不因没改被贬低。"
  },
  "baselineConclusion": "N_A01单次开放基线核心失败,不代表安琦开放形体/组合/表情方法无效,也不能外推生成模型可靠性;其他精确方案仍实际使用了该方法。"
}